Unreported / Non-Citable
Background
This appeal arose from orders at an 18-month permanency review hearing for Ernesto M. and Ana M. under Welfare and Institutions Code section 366.22. The juvenile court found that the Los Angeles County Department of Children and Family Services provided reasonable services to the children's mother, D.P., who has an intellectual disability, and granted a continuance of the hearing with further reunification services. Mother challenged the reasonable services finding; the children challenged the extension of services beyond 18 months under section 352.
The dependency case began after Mother was hospitalized for methamphetamine use in August 2023. The court sustained a section 300 petition in March 2024 and ordered reunification services tailored to Mother's needs, including substance abuse treatment, parenting education, counseling, and monitored visitation. Over the following year, DCFS and Regional Center providers coordinated extensive hands-on assistance, including calendar management, referrals, one-on-one program support, and therapeutic visits with Ana.
At the contested 18-month review hearing held over several days in May through July 2025, the court heard testimony from the social worker, Mother, and Regional Center personnel. On July 2, 2025, the court found reasonable services were provided, found Mother had made substantial progress, and found good cause to continue the hearing under section 352 while extending reunification services until a September 23, 2025 review.
The Court’s Holding
Substantial evidence supported the reasonable services finding. During the relevant review period from November 19, 2024 through July 2, 2025, the social worker maintained frequent contact with Mother and her support team, reviewed services and appointments with her regularly, and coordinated with successive Regional Center service coordinators. Although DCFS did not refer Mother to programs specifically designed for parents with intellectual disabilities, providers accommodated her disability through one-on-one substance abuse support, an aide-assisted parenting class, and repetitive, practical counseling techniques.
Mother's claims that DCFS failed to obtain an updated psychological evaluation or housing assistance did not undermine the finding. Her counsel never requested a psychological evaluation below, and the Regional Center had placed Mother in an assisted living facility with 24-hour support while assessing her for supported living services. Because Mother had not progressed to unmonitored visits and continued to need prompting during visits, the absence of independent housing assistance did not preclude a finding that the services provided were reasonable.
The juvenile court did not abuse its discretion under section 352 in continuing the hearing and extending reunification services. The court could reasonably find extraordinary circumstances based on Mother's intellectual disability, her compliance with her case plan, recent documented improvement in her parenting during therapeutic visits, and Regional Center efforts to secure supported living housing. The roughly three-month continuance was not contrary to the children's interests because they remained placed with the paternal grandparents, a permanency hearing likely would result in guardianship without changing placement, and both children had improving relationships with Mother.
Key Takeaways
- Reasonable reunification services for a parent with an intellectual disability may be established through coordinated, individualized accommodations even without referral to a disability-specific program.
- A parent's failure to obtain an updated psychological evaluation did not support reversal where counsel never requested one in the juvenile court.
- Housing assistance was not essential to reasonable services where the parent had not progressed beyond monitored visits and continued to need prompting to meet the children's needs during those visits.
- Section 352 permits a brief continuance of an 18-month review hearing and extension of reunification services where external barriers and recent progress constitute extraordinary circumstances and the delay is not contrary to the children's interests.
- Appellate review of a reasonable services finding is ordinarily limited to the period following the last such finding.
Why It Matters
This unpublished decision applies Michael G. v. Superior Court's framework for section 352 relief after the 18-month mark, showing that documented recent progress and external barriers such as disability-related limitations and pending supportive housing can justify a short extension even when the agency's services were otherwise reasonable.
The opinion also illustrates the practical standard for accommodating an intellectually disabled parent: the focus is on whether services were tailored and supported through individualized assistance and coordination, not whether ideal disability-specific programs were available.