California Case Summaries

In re D.C. — Court conditionally reverses termination of parental rights because the agency failed to contact two Kickapoo tribes after a relative claimed Kickapoo ancestry

Unreported / Non-Citable

Case
In re D.C.
Court
4th District Court of Appeal, Division One
Judge
Rubin (Gavin Newsom, 2023); Castillo (Gavin Newsom, 2023); Amin
Date Decided
2026-11-20
Docket No.
D088016
Status
Unreported / Non-Citable
Topics
dependency, juvenile court, Indian Child Welfare Act, ICWA inquiry, relative placement, section 361.3, termination of parental rights, conditional reversal

Background

In August 2024, the San Diego County Health and Human Services Agency petitioned regarding newborn D.C. after she tested positive for fentanyl at birth. After initial detention and placement with the paternal grandmother, the Agency removed D.C. in December 2024 because the grandmother routinely left her unattended at the maternal grandmother's home, where the parents had unauthorized access and fled with her. Following her return, D.C. again tested positive for fentanyl. D.C. was subsequently placed with her maternal aunt.

Although the paternal grandmother completed caregiver approval in October 2025, the court and Agency were not notified until December 2025, after reunification services had ended. At the April 2026 permanency hearing, the court held the relative placement preference under section 361.3 inapplicable because D.C. was in a stable placement. The court treated her request under section 388, summarily denied it, and entered an order on April 6, 2026, terminating parental rights.

During the proceedings, the paternal grandmother reported possible Kickapoo ancestry discovered through Ancestry.com. The Agency contacted the Kickapoo Tribe of Kansas, which confirmed non-membership, but failed to contact the Kickapoo Traditional Tribe of Texas or the Kickapoo Tribe of Oklahoma. The juvenile court found the Indian Child Welfare Act (ICWA) inapplicable, and both parents appealed.

The Court’s Holding

The California Court of Appeal, Fourth Appellate District, Division One, held the parents had standing because they actively contested termination below and appealed the April 6, 2026 order. The court affirmed the placement ruling, holding section 361.3 applies only at disposition or when a new placement must be made. Because D.C. was already in a stable home, no new placement was required. Any error was harmless given the grandmother's demonstrated lack of protective capacity and past exposure of D.C. to lethal drug risks.

The court held the finding that ICWA did not apply lacked substantial evidence because the Agency failed to conduct further inquiry with the two other federally recognized Kickapoo tribes under section 224.2. Accepting the Agency's concession, the court conditionally reversed the April 6, 2026 termination order and remanded for limited ICWA inquiry under In re Dezi C., directing reinstatement of the order if neither tribe claims the child.

Key Takeaways

  • The statutory duty of further inquiry under section 224.2 requires contacting all federally recognized tribes associated with a child's claimed heritage, not just a single branch.
  • Under In re Dezi C., failure to conduct an adequate ICWA inquiry warrants conditional reversal of a termination order and a limited remand to complete inquiry.
  • The relative placement preference in section 361.3 applies at disposition and thereafter only when a new placement is necessary, not to disrupt an existing stable relative placement.
  • Omission of a section 361.3 assessment is harmless where the relative's past failure to protect the child from drug hazards demonstrates placement is contrary to best interests.

Why It Matters

This decision illustrates the strict enforcement of ICWA inquiry duties under In re Dezi C., establishing that partial tribal outreach cannot support a finding that ICWA does not apply. It also confirms that section 361.3 does not require disturbing stable relative placements once reunification services have been terminated.

Read the full opinion (PDF) · Court docket

Scroll to Top