California Case Summaries

Ihab Kifah Nadhim v. Shantal Hernandez, et al. — Prisoner’s Bivens suit over alleged sexual coercion and threats is dismissed with leave to amend

Unreported / Non-Citable

Case
Ihab Kifah Nadhim v. Shantal Hernandez, et al.
Court
U.S. District Court — Southern District of California
Judge
Not specified
Date Decided
2026-11-19
Docket No.
3:26-cv-03794
Status
Unreported
Topics
Bivens, prisoner civil rights, screening, in forma pauperis, substantive due process, immigration detention

Background

Plaintiff Ihab Kifah Nadhim, a state prisoner proceeding pro se, filed a Bivens complaint alleging that DHS contractor Shantal Hernandez coerced him into sex under threats of deportation while he was detained at the Otay Mesa Detention Center, and later stalked him. He further alleged that ICE employee Rodney Richmond and ICE officer Sergio Rodriguez threatened to kill or deport him if he cooperated with internal affairs. The action was transferred to the Southern District of California.

After an initial in forma pauperis motion was denied for lack of a trust account statement, Nadhim filed two renewed motions. The court granted the first motion, assessed no initial partial fee, denied the second as moot, and screened the complaint before answer pursuant to 28 U.S.C. §§ 1915(e)(2) and 1915A(b).

The Court’s Holding

Liberally construing the complaint as alleging a Fifth Amendment substantive due process violation, the court held that Hernandez, as a privately employed contractor at the detention center, cannot be sued under Bivens pursuant to Minneci v. Pollard. As to Richmond and Rodriguez, the court held that verbal threats alone do not constitute a constitutional violation and that the allegations failed the Rule 12(b)(6) plausibility standard.

The court further held that a Fifth Amendment substantive due process claim arises in a new Bivens context that the Ninth Circuit declined to extend in Marquez v. Rodriguez. No special factors justified implying a damages remedy, and the court found no indication that Nadhim lacked alternative remedies such as administrative review or declaratory and injunctive relief. Nadhim admitted he did not utilize available administrative procedures, his conclusory fear of retaliation did not show they were unavailable, and he failed to show that declaratory or injunctive relief was unavailable.

Key Takeaways

  • A privately employed detention facility contractor is not subject to damages liability under Bivens pursuant to Minneci v. Pollard.
  • Verbal threats by federal officers do not constitute an independent constitutional violation and fail the Rule 12(b)(6) plausibility standard.
  • A Fifth Amendment substantive due process Bivens claim presents a new context that courts will not recognize where the plaintiff fails to show alternative remedies were unavailable.
  • A plaintiff's generalized fear of retaliation does not establish that administrative grievance procedures were effectively unavailable.
  • A pro se complaint dismissed upon statutory screening should be granted leave to amend unless amendment would be futile.

Why It Matters

The ruling illustrates how the Supreme Court's restrictive Bivens framework and Ninth Circuit precedent foreclose damages claims by immigration detainees against private contractors and where alternative remedies are not demonstrated to be unavailable.

The court granted Nadhim 45 days to file an amended complaint curing the pleading defects, warning that failure to amend would result in a final dismissal for failure to state a claim and failure to prosecute.

Read the full opinion (PDF) · Court docket

Scroll to Top