Unreported / Non-Citable
Background
Jose David Hernandez Rodriguez, Eva Sarai Galo Robles, and two derivative applicants, all Honduran nationals, petitioned for review after the Board of Immigration Appeals dismissed their appeal from an immigration judge’s denial of asylum, withholding of removal, and relief under the Convention Against Torture. The panel reviewed the BIA’s decision under the substantial-evidence standard because the BIA independently reviewed the immigration judge’s findings.
Petitioners argued that the agency failed to consider the individual applications of Robles and the two derivative applicants, and they relied on Hernandez’s account of an altercation with Officer Herrera, a death threat, a home burglary, and vehicle vandalism to establish persecution and a fear of future harm.
The Court’s Holding
The Ninth Circuit held that the due-process claim was unexhausted because petitioners never raised it before the BIA, and it would fail in any event because the derivative applicants asserted no independent grounds for relief and relied on Hernandez’s facts and claims.
Substantial evidence supported the agency’s findings that Hernandez’s altercation and single death threat did not constitute persecution, that petitioners did not show police caused the burglary or vandalism, and that the record did not establish a well-founded fear of future persecution. Without past persecution, no presumption of future persecution arose, and withholding of removal failed as well. Petitioners forfeited any challenge to the CAT determination by not addressing it in their opening brief.
Key Takeaways
- A due-process challenge not presented to the BIA is unexhausted under 8 U.S.C. § 1252(d)(1), and the court may enforce that claims-processing rule when the government properly raises it.
- An altercation without significant physical injuries and a single death threat that caused no physical harm ordinarily do not compel a finding of persecution under the substantial-evidence standard.
- Failure to establish past persecution removes the rebuttable presumption of future persecution and, absent a well-founded fear, defeats withholding of removal.
- Arguments omitted from an opening brief, including challenges to CAT eligibility, are forfeited.
Why It Matters
The unpublished memorandum applies settled substantial-evidence and exhaustion principles to a family-based asylum petition, emphasizing that generalized country-conditions evidence not particularized to the petitioners cannot compel a contrary conclusion.
The court also denied the pending motion to stay removal, making the petition denial immediately operative as to the requested relief.