California Case Summaries

Galbaatar Bat Erdene v. Markwayne Mullin, et al. — Court grants habeas petition and orders release because government forfeited response to unopposed due process claim

Unreported / Non-Citable

Case
Galbaatar Bat Erdene v. Markwayne Mullin, et al.
Court
U.S. District Court — Central District of California
Judge
Brianna Fuller Mircheff (Judges of the U.S. District Court for the Central District of California, 2023)
Date Decided
2026-11-16
Docket No.
5:26-cv-06581
Status
Unreported
Topics
immigration detention, habeas corpus, procedural due process, forfeiture, party presentation principle, release order

Background

Petitioner Galbaatar Bat Erdene, a noncitizen detained at the Adelanto Detention Facility, entered the United States with his wife on an F1 visa in January 2019 and filed asylum applications in April 2021. Since 2019, Bat Erdene has established strong family roots in the United States alongside his wife and their young United States citizen son, maintaining an unblemished record free of criminal history. On October 3, 2026, Immigration and Customs Enforcement arrested Bat Erdene at Los Angeles International Airport, and he remained detained at Adelanto thereafter.

Bat Erdene filed a 28 U.S.C. § 2241 habeas petition on November 5, 2026, alleging that immigration authorities provided no pre-deprivation custody determination or notice explaining the legal basis for his detention. He argued that these procedural due process violations rendered his confinement unlawful and warranted immediate release from custody.

In response, the government addressed only a bond determination petitioner never challenged, asserting that he received an adequate bond hearing and failed to exhaust administrative remedies regarding that bond determination. Bat Erdene replied that respondents completely failed to address his due process challenge to his initial detention. The magistrate judge deemed the petition ripe for disposition.

The Court’s Holding

The court granted the petition as to petitioner's due process claim, holding that respondents' failure to oppose the claim actually asserted constituted forfeiture. Under the party presentation principle, federal courts act as neutral arbiters tasked with deciding only the specific issues framed by the parties. Because respondents were represented by competent counsel with full access to the facts concerning petitioner's detention and offered no factual or legal basis to oppose the initial-detention claim, the court declined to search for defenses on their behalf.

The court explained that it need not decide whether it agrees with the merits of petitioner's claims in all respects, because his claim that detention lacked lawful authority remained unrefuted. Applying Ninth Circuit precedent holding that unsupported arguments are waived or abandoned, the court concluded that respondents failed to carry their statutory burden under 28 U.S.C. § 2243 to show cause why the writ should not be granted.

The operative order commands that Bat Erdene be immediately released on reasonable conditions. Petitioner's counsel must file a status report confirming release within three days, or promptly notify the court if release is delayed. Upon receipt of confirmation that petitioner has been released, judgment will issue and the court will close the case. Any application for attorney fees under the Equal Access to Justice Act must be timely filed.

Key Takeaways

  • When the government addresses an unasserted bond claim rather than answering the petitioner's actual due process challenge to initial detention, that failure constitutes forfeiture of available defenses.
  • Federal courts adhere to the party presentation principle by resolving only issues presented by the litigants, rather than creating legal theories or arguments on behalf of represented parties.
  • The magistrate judge emphasized that the court need not decide whether it agrees with the merits of petitioner's claims in all respects, because the government's silence left the challenge unrefuted.
  • The court granted the writ under 28 U.S.C. § 2243 and ordered immediate release on reasonable conditions, reserving formal judgment and case closure until counsel files a status report confirming actual release.
  • Government arguments regarding administrative exhaustion of immigration bond determinations are inapposite and cannot defeat a habeas petition directed exclusively at the constitutional validity of initial civil detention.

Why It Matters

This decision underscores the practical vitality of the party presentation principle in immigration habeas litigation. In 28 U.S.C. § 2241 proceedings, the government cannot rely on generic, tangential arguments concerning bond hearing adequacy or administrative exhaustion when the petition attacks the constitutional validity of initial arrest and detention. By declining to supply defenses that the government omitted, the court made clear that federal judges will not rescue represented respondents who fail to oppose the actual claims asserted.

The ruling also illustrates a pragmatic procedural approach to granting habeas relief in immigration custody matters. By commanding immediate release on reasonable conditions while conditioning final judgment on counsel's post-release status report, the court established a verified mechanism ensuring compliance with its mandate before closing the judicial file, while keeping the door open for timely fee applications under the Equal Access to Justice Act.

Read the full opinion (PDF) · Court docket

Scroll to Top