California Case Summaries

Emily Lucas v. The Regents of the University of California, et al. — Court Sets Oral Argument on Preclusion and Quasi-Judicial Immunity Questions Without Ruling on the Motion to Dismiss

Unreported / Non-Citable

Case
Emily Lucas v. The Regents of the University of California, et al.
Court
U.S. District Court — Southern District of California
Judge
Cynthia Bashant (Barack Obama, 2014)
Date Decided
2026-11-13
Docket No.
3:26-cv-02774
Status
Unreported
Topics
Southern District of California, motion to dismiss, oral argument order, issue preclusion, judicial exhaustion, Jamgotchian v. Ferraro, Doe v. Regents, quasi-judicial immunity, school disciplinary proceedings, Burns v. Reed, Cleavinger v. Saxner

Background

Plaintiff Emily Lucas sued The Regents of the University of California and related University Defendants in the United States District Court for the Southern District of California, Case No. 26-cv-2774-BAS-DEB. The University Defendants have moved to dismiss under ECF No. 21. The order dated November 13, 2026, signed by Chief Judge Cynthia Bashant, does not decide that motion. Instead, it directs Plaintiff and the University Defendants to appear for oral argument in Courtroom 12B on Friday, December 4, 2026, at 1:30 p.m.

The court identified two subject areas for argument. The first concerns the University Defendants' judicial exhaustion argument, which relies on Doe v. Regents of the University of California, 891 F.3d 1147 (9th Cir. 2018). The court stated that Jamgotchian v. Ferraro, 93 F.4th 1150 (9th Cir. 2024), cast serious doubt on the continued vitality of Doe. The second concerns quasi-judicial immunity for defendants identified as Trapp and Schaps, whom the order describes as school administrators presiding over or managing disciplinary proceedings.

The order states that the parties should be prepared to discuss the motion's points and authorities along with the specific questions the court listed. The record provided contains no party briefs, so the order's descriptions of the arguments are limited to what the court itself wrote.

The Court’s Holding

The order is procedural. It does not grant or deny the motion to dismiss, does not resolve any preclusion or immunity question, and does not dismiss any claim. Its substance lies in the questions it poses for argument.

On preclusion, the court asked two questions: first, how Jamgotchian applies or fails to apply to this case; and second, how the disciplinary proceedings here satisfy the two-step inquiry Jamgotchian described for giving preclusive effect to a state agency proceeding. The court did not state an answer to either question.

On immunity, the court wrote that it had reviewed the cited quasi-judicial immunity cases and that none applies quasi-judicial immunity to public school administrators conducting adversarial disciplinary proceedings. It said it had found no such case in its own research. It asked whether any case applies the doctrine to comparable administrators, whether the issue is one of first impression, whether a lack of such authority fits the Supreme Court's statement in Burns v. Reed, 500 U.S. 478, 487 (1991), that it has been "quite sparing" in recognizing absolute immunity, and whether the facts are closer to Cleavinger v. Saxner, 474 U.S. 193 (1985), which denied absolute immunity to prison disciplinary officials.

Key Takeaways

  • The November 13, 2026 order sets a December 4, 2026 oral argument on the University Defendants' motion to dismiss and does not itself resolve that motion.
  • The court has signaled doubt about whether Doe v. Regents, 891 F.3d 1147 (9th Cir. 2018), still supports the University Defendants' judicial exhaustion argument after Jamgotchian v. Ferraro, 93 F.4th 1150 (9th Cir. 2024).
  • The court asked the parties to explain how the disciplinary proceedings satisfy the two-step inquiry that Jamgotchian described for preclusive effect of state agency proceedings.
  • The court stated that it found no authority applying quasi-judicial immunity to public school administrators in adversarial disciplinary proceedings and framed that as a possible issue of first impression.
  • The court asked whether the case is closer to Cleavinger v. Saxner, 474 U.S. 193 (1985), which denied absolute immunity to prison disciplinary officials, and how any lack of authority fits Burns v. Reed's description of the Supreme Court's sparing approach to absolute immunity.

Why It Matters

The order is significant mainly for what it reveals about the court's concerns before argument. By flagging Jamgotchian as casting serious doubt on Doe, the court has put the continued force of a Ninth Circuit preclusion precedent at the center of the University Defendants' exhaustion argument. Parties and practitioners in the Ninth Circuit may treat this as a signal to examine whether Doe still governs preclusion from state university disciplinary findings.

The immunity questions are open. The court's statement that it found no comparable quasi-judicial immunity decisions, together with its reference to Burns and Cleavinger, shows that the court is weighing whether to extend absolute immunity to school disciplinary administrators. Any eventual ruling on these points would be the first step in resolving the issue, and the order does not decide it. Readers should check the December 4 argument record and any later written ruling for the court's actual conclusions.

Read the full opinion (PDF) · Court docket

Scroll to Top