Unreported / Non-Citable
Background
Plaintiffs, proceeding pro se, brought a wrongful death civil rights action arising from Kevin S. Dresdner's death while he was incarcerated at the Sacramento County Jail. The case was referred to a magistrate judge for findings and recommendations under 28 U.S.C. § 636(b)(1)(B) and Local Rule 302(c)(21).
On March 10, 2026, the magistrate judge recommended striking plaintiffs' third amended complaint as untimely and dismissing claims against Chris Carlson, Jim Cooper, and putative claims against Sacramento County without prejudice but without further leave to amend at that time. The recommendations also called for dismissal with prejudice of claims against Sacramento County Jail, Adult Correctional Health, and the California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation, as well as the HIPAA claim.
Plaintiff Cheryl D. Dresdner objected, focusing on the treatment of Doe defendants and plaintiffs' efforts to identify them. The district judge explained that Rule 15, rather than state Doe-pleading practice, governs adding defendants and relation back, and that plaintiffs could seek identities through discovery and later move to amend if they could make the required showing.
The Court’s Holding
After de novo review of the entire file, the court found the findings and recommendations supported by the record and proper analysis and adopted them in full.
The court struck the third amended complaint as untimely; dismissed the claims against Carlson and Cooper and the putative claims against Sacramento County without prejudice but without further leave to amend at this time; dismissed with prejudice the claims against Sacramento County Jail, Adult Correctional Health, and the California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation; and dismissed the HIPAA claim with prejudice.
The action was referred back to the assigned magistrate judge for further proceedings, so the order did not end the case.
Key Takeaways
- An untimely third amended complaint may be stricken even where plaintiffs are proceeding pro se and have tried to identify Doe defendants.
- The court distinguished dismissal without prejudice from the denial of further leave to amend at that time, while preserving the possibility of a later Rule 15 motion supported by a proper showing.
- Claims against the Sacramento County Jail, Adult Correctional Health, and the California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation were dismissed with prejudice, as was the HIPAA claim.
- The order adopted a magistrate judge's recommendations only after de novo review and consideration of plaintiffs' objections.
Why It Matters
The order illustrates how federal Rule 15 controls the addition of newly identified defendants and relation-back questions, displacing state-law Doe-pleading assumptions in a pro se civil-rights case.
It also shows that screening dismissals can be partly without prejudice and partly with prejudice, with the case continuing before the magistrate judge after the district judge adopts the recommendations.