California Case Summaries

Jane Roe 6 v. International Churches of Christ, Inc. — Dissolution of One Corporate Entity Does Not Support Judgment on the Pleadings for Co-Defendants

Unreported / Non-Citable

Case
Jane Roe 6 v. International Churches of Christ, Inc.
Court
2nd District Court of Appeal
Judge
Zukin, P. J. (Gavin Newsom, 2023); Mori, J. (Gavin Newsom, 2023); Tamzarian, J. (Gavin Newsom, 2025)
Date Decided
2026-11-18
Docket No.
B349364
Status
Unreported / Non-Citable
Topics
judgment on the pleadings, corporate dissolution, vicarious liability, forfeiture on appeal, leave to amend

Background

Plaintiffs Jane Roe 6 and Jane Roe 7 brought a second amended complaint against several corporate entities and individual church leaders, including Los Angeles International Church of Christ (LA ICOC) and International Churches of Christ, Inc. (ICOC, Inc.). Plaintiffs asserted nine causes of action arising from alleged childhood sexual assaults perpetrated by church members in 2011 and 2015, alleging vicarious liability and efforts by church leaders to dissuade reporting.

Defendants jointly moved for judgment on the pleadings, asserting that the complaint failed to plead facts establishing vicarious liability or a special relationship imposing a duty to control parishioners. Defendants additionally argued that ICOC, Inc. had dissolved in 2010, barring claims against it that arose wholly post-dissolution under Corporations Code section 2010. The trial court concluded that ICOC, Inc.'s dissolution was dispositive and granted judgment on the pleadings without leave to amend as to all defendants without reaching alternative arguments.

The Court’s Holding

The Court of Appeal affirmed the judgment on the pleadings as to ICOC, Inc. without leave to amend, concluding that plaintiffs forfeited their challenges to the effect of corporate dissolution by failing to develop citations or substantive arguments in the trial court, omitting a reporter's transcript, and failing to contest defendants' forfeiture showing on appeal.

However, the appellate court vacated the judgment and reversed the order as to the remaining defendants. The court determined that ICOC, Inc.'s 2010 corporate dissolution did not bar claims against other distinct entities and individual church leaders as a matter of law. Because the trial court did not evaluate the alternative grounds concerning the sufficiency of vicarious liability allegations or whether leave to amend was warranted, the matter was remanded for consideration of those arguments in the first instance.

Key Takeaways

  • Under California Corporations Code section 2010, a dissolved corporation may only be sued for injury caused by predissolution activities, barring claims that arise wholly post-dissolution.
  • A defense unique to one entity, such as pre-injury corporate dissolution, cannot serve as a blanket ground to grant judgment on the pleadings for unrelated co-defendants.
  • Appellate courts will exercise judicial restraint and remand unadjudicated demurrer or judgment on the pleadings challenges concerning pleading sufficiency so the trial court may determine leave to amend in the first instance.
  • Failure to substantiate legal arguments before the trial court and the omission of an adequate hearing record forfeits appellate review of trial-level dispositive rulings.

Why It Matters

This decision emphasizes that trial courts cannot treat a dispositive defense personal to a single entity as a global ground to terminate claims against affiliated co-defendants. It underscores the critical requirement that motions directed at pleadings must be analyzed individually as to each defendant.

The ruling also illustrates the strict application of appellate forfeiture where an opposing party fails to produce legal authority in trial court briefing, lacks a hearing transcript, and does not file a reply brief to contest forfeiture arguments on appeal.

Read the full opinion (PDF) · Court docket

Scroll to Top