California Case Summaries

Santiago Teodomiro Gonzalez Perez v. Markwayne Mullin et al. — Court orders immediate release because ICE detained petitioner for over a month without producing an arrest warrant or serving a Notice to Appear

Unreported / Non-Citable

Case
Santiago Teodomiro Gonzalez Perez v. Markwayne Mullin et al.
Court
U.S. District Court — Central District of California
Judge
Rozella A. Oliver (magistrate judge)
Date Decided
2026-11-16
Docket No.
5:26-cv-06534
Status
Unreported
Topics
immigration detention, habeas corpus, arrest warrant, Notice to Appear, unnecessary delay, release remedy, injunction against redetention

Background

Santiago Teodomiro Gonzalez Perez, a Mexican citizen represented by counsel, entered the United States without inspection in 1999 and had lived and worked here continuously for more than 20 years as a car upholsterer. He supported his domestic partner and her daughter, belonged to a church in Riverside, and had community ties. On October 14, 2026, ICE agents conducting a vehicle stop while targeting someone else arrested petitioner after he presented a consular card and acknowledged that he lacked legal status. He filed this habeas petition on November 3, 2026; respondents responded on November 10 and petitioner replied on November 11.

The Form I-213 stated that an arrest warrant had been authorized and that a Notice to Appear would be processed after petitioner was taken into ICE custody. But the petition and reply said petitioner and his counsel had received neither document, and respondents supplied no copies with their response. The petition raised three claims: detention without a pre-deprivation hearing violated due process; the arrest was warrantless or made without a likelihood of escape in violation of the Immigration and Nationality Act; and the arrest before issuance of the NTA was illegal. Respondents did not address the merits, instead suggesting petitioner appeared entitled to a bond hearing under Rodriguez Vazquez v. Bostock because this was his first detention as a noncitizen who entered without inspection.

The Court’s Holding

The court granted habeas relief on the INA claim (count two). It reasoned that federal agencies must follow their own binding procedures, and that 8 U.S.C. § 1357(a)(2) and 8 C.F.R. § 287.3(c) required action without unnecessary delay in issuing the NTA and related initial custody documents. Although the court took judicial notice of EOIR records suggesting an NTA had been filed with the immigration court by October 19, the undisputed record showed the NTA had never been served on petitioner and no arrest warrant had been produced. The court characterized the warrant and prompt-notice requirements as guardrails against unjustified detention and found those guardrails were ignored here.

Because more than a month elapsed without petitioner being provided the arrest warrant or NTA, the court selected release as the appropriate remedy, noting courts have flexibility in fashioning habeas relief. It ordered respondents to release petitioner immediately, enjoined them from re-detaining him absent strict compliance with due process and all applicable statutes and regulations, and required a notice of compliance within two days confirming his release. The due-process and pre-NTA-arrest counts were denied as moot.

Key Takeaways

  • ICE's failure for more than a month to provide either an arrest warrant or a served Notice to Appear supported immediate release as habeas relief under the court's analysis of 8 U.S.C. § 1357(a)(2) and 8 C.F.R. § 287.3(c).
  • Filing an NTA with EOIR did not cure the violation where the undisputed record showed the NTA was never served on the detained person.
  • The order's injunction bars re-detention absent strict compliance with due process and applicable statutes and regulations, giving the release order continuing effect.
  • Respondents' failure to address the petition's merits did not prevent adjudication; the court resolved the statutory claim on the record before it and treated the remaining counts as moot after ordering release.

Why It Matters

This order illustrates how habeas courts in the Central District of California are enforcing the prompt-processing requirements governing immigration arrests, treating the warrant and NTA timing rules as substantive protections rather than technicalities. It also shows that agency reliance on later-filed removal paperwork will not substitute for serving the detained person with the charging document.

The remedy is notable for combining immediate release with an injunction against re-detention absent full legal compliance and a short compliance-reporting deadline, giving detained petitioners practical relief beyond a declaration of illegality.

Read the full opinion (PDF) · Court docket

Scroll to Top