Unreported / Non-Citable
Background
Rogelio Ramirez Lopez, a native and citizen of Mexico, petitioned the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit for review of an order of the Board of Immigration Appeals (BIA) dismissing his appeal from an immigration judge's decision. The immigration judge had denied his applications for asylum, withholding of removal, protection under the Convention Against Torture (CAT), and cancellation of removal.
Before the Ninth Circuit, Ramirez Lopez sought review of the agency's findings, contending that he established changed circumstances to excuse his untimely asylum application and challenging the denial of withholding of removal, CAT protection, and cancellation of removal. The court exercised jurisdiction under 8 U.S.C. § 1252, reviewing factual findings and hardship determinations under the substantial evidence standard, and legal questions de novo.
The Court’s Holding
The Ninth Circuit denied the petition for review. The panel held that the agency did not err in determining that Ramirez Lopez failed to demonstrate changed circumstances to excuse his untimely asylum application under 8 U.S.C. § 1158(a)(2)(D) and 8 C.F.R. § 1208.4(a)(4), as new evidence merely confirming previously known facts did not excuse the delay. Additionally, because Ramirez Lopez did not challenge the agency's determination that he failed to demonstrate extraordinary circumstances, the court did not address that exception. Regarding withholding of removal, the panel held that Ramirez Lopez waived the claim by failing to challenge the agency's dispositive determination that his proposed particular social group was not cognizable.
The court further held that substantial evidence supported the agency's denial of CAT protection because Ramirez Lopez failed to show that it was more likely than not that he would suffer torture by or with the consent or acquiescence of the Mexican government upon return. Substantial evidence likewise supported the determination that he failed to establish exceptional and extremely unusual hardship to a qualifying relative for cancellation of removal, which requires hardship substantially beyond that ordinarily expected from family separation. In light of these dispositive rulings, the court declined to reach Ramirez Lopez's remaining contentions regarding the merits and denied his pending motion to stay removal as moot.
Key Takeaways
- Under 8 U.S.C. § 1158(a)(2)(D), newly submitted evidence that merely confirms facts already known to the applicant does not establish changed circumstances sufficient to excuse an untimely asylum filing.
- An applicant for withholding of removal waives appellate challenge by failing to contest the agency's dispositive ruling that their proposed particular social group is legally non-cognizable.
- Protection under the Convention Against Torture requires affirmative proof that the petitioner is more likely than not to face torture inflicted by or with the consent or acquiescence of public officials.
- Cancellation of removal requires demonstrating exceptional and extremely unusual hardship to a qualifying relative that is substantially beyond the ordinary distress accompanying a close relative's departure from the United States.
Why It Matters
This decision illustrates the Ninth Circuit's rigorous enforcement of procedural thresholds and deferential standards of review in immigration appeals. By declining to excuse an untimely asylum application based on cumulative evidence and deeming uncontested particular social group findings waived, the memorandum underscores the necessity of preserving specific challenges at every stage of administrative review. It also reaffirms the high evidentiary bar required to prove government acquiescence under CAT and exceptional hardship for cancellation of removal.