California Case Summaries

Reyna Mendez-De Vasquez v. Todd Blanche — Ninth Circuit denies petition because gang extortion lacked protected-ground nexus and no official acquiescence in torture was shown

Unreported / Non-Citable

Case
Reyna Mendez-De Vasquez v. Todd Blanche
Court
Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals
Judge
McKeown (Bill Clinton, 1998); W. Fletcher (William J. Clinton, 1998); Desai (Joe Biden, 2022)
Date Decided
2026-11-18
Docket No.
20-70898
Status
Unreported
Topics
immigration, asylum, withholding of removal, Convention Against Torture, nexus, waiver, gang extortion, substantial evidence

Background

Reyna Araceli Mendez-de Vasquez and her children, natives and citizens of El Salvador, petitioned for review of a Board of Immigration Appeals decision affirming an Immigration Judge's denial of their applications for asylum, withholding of removal, and protection under the Convention Against Torture. The unpublished memorandum was submitted November 16, 2026, in Seattle, and decided by a panel of McKeown, W. Fletcher, and Desai, Circuit Judges.

The panel reviewed the BIA's decision together with the parts of the IJ decision on which it relied, applying de novo review to legal questions and substantial-evidence review to the agency's factual findings. Petitioners also had a pending motion for stay of removal.

The court first found waiver: although the petitioners' brief purported to address nexus, it argued instead that the proposed social group "female heads of household" is cognizable, an issue the agency never reached. The agency's findings on nexus and acquiescence were dispositive of the asylum and withholding claims and the CAT claim respectively.

The Court’s Holding

On the merits, the court held that substantial evidence supported the agency's finding of no nexus to a protected ground. The record showed a gang targeted Mendez-de Vasquez for extortion out of a desire for money, not because of a protected trait, and asylum is unavailable to victims of indiscriminate violence unless singled out on account of a protected ground.

The court separately held that substantial evidence supported denial of CAT relief because petitioners offered no evidence that any alleged harm would occur with the consent or acquiescence of a public official, and generalized country-conditions evidence cannot establish a likely torture risk. The panel denied the stay motion and denied the petition.

Key Takeaways

  • A petition for review that argues only the cognizability of a proposed social group does not preserve challenges to the agency's nexus and acquiescence findings when those findings are dispositive.
  • Extortion motivated by a desire for money, without evidence the victim was selected because of a protected trait, does not establish the nexus required for asylum or withholding of removal.
  • CAT protection requires evidence that torture would more likely than not occur with the consent or acquiescence of a public official; generalized country-conditions evidence is insufficient.

Why It Matters

This unpublished memorandum illustrates how waiver can independently defeat an immigration petition where the brief addresses an issue the agency did not reach, while also confirming that purely economic gang extortion generally fails the protected-ground nexus requirement.

The decision also reinforces the demanding CAT standard, requiring individualized evidence of likely official consent or acquiescence rather than general reports of country conditions.

Read the full opinion (PDF) · Court docket

Scroll to Top