Unreported / Non-Citable
Background
Petitioner Kulwinder Singh, an immigration detainee at the Mesa Verde ICE Processing Center, petitioned for a writ of habeas corpus and moved for a temporary restraining order under 28 U.S.C. § 2241, alleging that summary detention without notice or a pre-deprivation hearing violated Fifth Amendment due process. The district court consolidated the matters, directing respondents to show why established precedent recognizing a protected liberty interest in continued conditional release did not govern.
Singh entered the United States in September 2023 at Lukeville, Arizona, was placed in removal proceedings, and was released on his own recognizance. He complied with all release conditions, including attending check-ins, submitting an asylum application, completing biometrics, and promptly reporting address updates. Nevertheless, immigration officials sent hearing notices to an incorrect address, causing Singh to miss an April 16, 2026 hearing of which he lacked notice, whereupon an immigration judge entered an in absentia removal order.
On October 13, 2026, Singh reported to the Sacramento ICE office for a scheduled check-in and was arrested under the undisclosed in absentia order. While detained, he retained counsel and moved to reopen and rescind the removal order for lack of notice. That motion remained pending before the immigration court. The government argued detention was mandatory under 8 U.S.C. § 1231(a)(2) on the theory that the order became final on October 11, 2026, whereas Singh argued the order was not final when arrested and that removal was stayed.
The Court’s Holding
The court held that Singh's removal order was not final when ICE arrested him on October 13, 2026. Under Cui v. Garland, an in absentia removal order does not become final until the 180-day deadline for filing a motion to reopen under 8 U.S.C. § 1229a(b)(5)(C)(i) expires. Calculating 180 days from April 16, 2026, the statutory window ended on October 13, 2026, not October 11 as respondents maintained. Because Singh was arrested within that active reopening window, the order was not final, and ICE lacked statutory detention authority under § 1231(a)(2).
The court further determined that even assuming the order subsequently became final after 180 days, due process required Singh's release. Noncitizens released on conditional parole retain a protected liberty interest in continued freedom, requiring notice and a pre-deprivation hearing before release can be revoked. Although respondents asserted detention was authorized once 180 days elapsed, Singh's pending motion to reopen triggered an automatic stay of removal under 8 U.S.C. § 1229a(b)(5)(C). Because the government could not execute the removal order and showed no justification for revoking parole, continued detention was unlawful.
The court granted the habeas petition and ordered respondents to release Singh immediately, without additional restrictions absent a future custody hearing. The court permanently enjoined the government from re-arresting or re-detaining him without constitutional protections, including advance notice of changed circumstances and a timely hearing where the government must establish flight risk or dangerousness by clear and convincing evidence with counsel present. The order left open whether re-detention would be permissible if the removal order becomes executable.
Key Takeaways
- An in absentia removal order does not become administratively final until the 180-day statutory period to move to reopen before an immigration judge expires.
- Immigration authorities lack statutory detention authority under 8 U.S.C. § 1231(a)(2) when arresting a noncitizen before the 180-day reopening period concludes.
- Noncitizens released on conditional parole retain a constitutionally protected liberty interest in continued freedom requiring notice and a hearing before release can be revoked.
- Filing a motion to reopen an in absentia order automatically stays removal under 8 U.S.C. § 1229a(b)(5)(C), barring mandatory detention based on an unexecutable order.
- Any future re-detention requires advance notice, counsel representation, and clear and convincing evidence demonstrating flight risk or danger to the community.
Why It Matters
This decision strictly applies Ninth Circuit finality precedent from Cui v. Garland to defeat government attempts to execute in absentia removal orders prematurely. By enforcing the statutory calendar, the ruling establishes that immigration authorities cannot treat in absentia orders as final while the 180-day deadline remains open, invalidating arrests executed before expiration.
Furthermore, the decision reinforces procedural due process limits on immigration detention by coupling conditional parole liberty interests with the statutory stay in 8 U.S.C. § 1229a(b)(5)(C). By requiring clear and convincing proof at a pre-deprivation hearing, the ruling prevents agencies from circumventing procedural safeguards through premature detention under post-removal statutes.