Unreported / Non-Citable
Background
Gul Naz Akbari, an Afghan citizen who fled the Taliban, entered the United States in May 2025 and was placed in expedited removal proceedings. After she expressed a credible fear of persecution, an immigration judge vacated an initial negative screening and transferred her to standard removal proceedings. Her case was subsequently continued sixteen times. Although her initial immigration hearing occurred on September 19, 2025, after four months in custody, government records showed that her first master calendar hearing was delayed until January 28, 2026, leaving an eight-month post-arrest gap unexplained. During seventeen months in civil detention, Akbari attempted suicide, was classified as an ongoing suicide risk, suffered severe hypertension and substantial weight loss, and required multiple emergency hospitalizations due to inadequate medical care at California City Detention Facility.
On September 17, 2026, Akbari filed a 28 U.S.C. § 2241 habeas petition asserting procedural and substantive due process violations from prolonged detention without a bond hearing, seeking immediate release or an individualized bond hearing. On October 13, 2026, an immigration judge denied asylum but granted Akbari withholding of removal based on persecution for supporting women's and Hazara rights in Afghanistan. The government stated it would not appeal the withholding grant. Akbari submitted traverse evidence establishing community sponsorship and transitional housing. Although the magistrate judge ordered supplemental briefing on procedural delays and substantive due process, the government failed to address the substantive due process claim.
The Court’s Holding
Applying the five-factor substantive due process test from Doe v. Becerra, the magistrate judge analyzed detention length, government-caused delay, flight and danger risk, less restrictive alternatives, and confinement conditions. The magistrate judge observed that detention exceeding seventeen months without any bond hearing was prolonged. Although duration alone was not conclusive, unexplained government delays—including an eight-month delay before the initial master calendar hearing and numerous sua sponte continuances—weighed heavily against the government. Furthermore, Akbari had no criminal history, posed no danger, and presented minimal flight risk following her grant of withholding of removal, which rendered removal improbable. Available community housing, sponsorship, and electronic monitoring offered viable alternatives to continued detention.
Addressing the conditions of confinement, the magistrate judge found that confining a civil detainee with severe psychological distress and documented suicide risk in prison-like conditions rendered the confinement unconstitutionally punitive. In the operative order, the magistrate judge denied Akbari's motion for appointment of counsel as unnecessary in light of the relief recommended. The magistrate judge recommended granting habeas relief on Count one (substantive due process) and Count two (prolonged detention), ordering immediate release under standard supervision conditions with the return of all documents and possessions. Although footnote three noted that Counts II and III were not addressed for judicial economy, the formal recommendation explicitly granted relief under Counts one and two. Finally, the magistrate judge recommended that any adoption order leave open future detention if an executable removal order arises with proper notice, and fixed a shortened three-day objection period.
Key Takeaways
- Prolonged civil immigration detention violates substantive due process when its duration and conditions become excessive in relation to regulatory purposes such as preventing flight and protecting community safety.
- Unexplained government-caused delays, the total denial of an individualized bond hearing, and the availability of feasible community release alternatives weigh heavily toward establishing that civil confinement is punitive.
- A grant of withholding of removal substantially undercuts the justification for mandatory detention because actual removal becomes improbable and any flight risk is markedly diminished.
- Severe mental health crises, including documented suicide attempts and risk, when coupled with harsh prison-like facility conditions, demonstrate that continued detention exceeds constitutional bounds.
- A magistrate judge's findings and recommendations proposing immediate release remain subject to district judge review, with the court here imposing a shortened three-day objection period under 28 U.S.C. § 636(b)(1).
Why It Matters
This decision reinforces Eastern District of California jurisprudence applying substantive due process limits to prolonged immigration detention under 8 U.S.C. § 1225(b), establishing that detention cannot continue when its regulatory justification ceases. By recognizing that a grant of withholding of removal largely eliminates the government's interest in detention pending removal, the recommendation underscores that civil detention authority remains strictly subordinate to constitutional guarantees. Additionally, the magistrate judge's recommendation of immediate supervised release under 28 U.S.C. § 2243, rather than remand for an immigration bond hearing, highlights the court's equitable authority to remedy punitive confinement.