Unreported / Non-Citable
Background
Petitioner Mehrdad Afsari, a native of Iran, entered the United States on July 4, 2025, without legal status and was immediately detained by U.S. Border Patrol. In November 2025, the Department of Homeland Security identified Afsari as a class member under the Franco-Gonzalez v. Holder permanent injunction, which mandates competency inquiries for detained noncitizens. A forensic examiner, Dr. Jones, evaluated Afsari and concluded that he was malingering, lacked any psychiatric condition impairing his functioning, and was competent to represent himself. On February 12, 2026, an Immigration Judge adopted those conclusions and found Afsari competent.
Throughout the proceedings, an Immigration Judge conducted three separate bond hearings on January 7, June 16, and October 2, 2026. Afsari represented himself at each hearing, and the judge denied bond each time after determining he posed a flight risk. On May 14, 2026, an Immigration Judge ordered Afsari removed to Iran, which Afsari appealed to the Board of Immigration Appeals. While that appeal remained pending, Afsari filed an amended habeas corpus petition under 28 U.S.C. § 2241, asserting that his prolonged mandatory detention had become unconstitutional because his competency assessment was inadequate.
The government opposed the petition, contending that Afsari was subject to mandatory detention, that 8 U.S.C. § 1252(g) stripped the court of jurisdiction, that Afsari had received three bond hearings, and that he failed to exhaust administrative remedies by not appealing any bond denial. Attached to his amended petition as Exhibit H, Afsari submitted an evaluation from Dr. Shibley challenging Dr. Jones's competency findings, and he subsequently filed a traverse.
The Court’s Holding
Chief Judge Cynthia Bashant denied the amended habeas corpus petition. As a threshold matter, the court held that 8 U.S.C. § 1252(g) did not bar subject-matter jurisdiction. Relying on Supreme Court and Ninth Circuit precedent, the court emphasized that § 1252(g) is interpreted narrowly to cover only three discrete actions: commencing proceedings, adjudicating cases, or executing removal orders. Because Afsari challenged the constitutional adequacy of his prolonged custody and bond hearings rather than the commencement, adjudication, or execution of removal, his bond claims were legally independent of the removal proceedings and remained within federal habeas jurisdiction.
Addressing the merits, the court acknowledged that detention without process can become arbitrarily or unreasonably prolonged in violation of due process, but highlighted that Afsari received three individualized bond hearings where an Immigration Judge determined he was a flight risk. The court observed that Afsari's constitutional claim fundamentally challenged the evidentiary basis of the competency determination and the Immigration Judge's reliance on Dr. Jones's forensic report. Because Afsari failed to appeal any of the three bond denials to the Board of Immigration Appeals, the court concluded that he failed to satisfy the prudential administrative exhaustion requirement.
The court explained that although 28 U.S.C. § 2241 does not contain an express statutory exhaustion command, prudential exhaustion is ordinarily not optional. Requiring appeal to the Board of Immigration Appeals provides agency expertise, affords the agency an opportunity to correct its own errors regarding expert evidence, and prevents deliberate bypass of administrative channels. Because Afsari demonstrated none of the established exceptions to exhaustion—such as administrative inadequacy, futility, irreparable injury, or void proceedings—the court held that administrative appeal to the Board of Immigration Appeals was a mandatory prerequisite before seeking habeas intervention.
Key Takeaways
- The jurisdictional restriction in 8 U.S.C. § 1252(g) applies narrowly to decisions to commence proceedings, adjudicate cases, or execute removal orders, preserving district court jurisdiction over independent custody and bond determinations.
- Detainees challenging bond proceedings based on allegedly improper psychiatric competency findings under Franco-Gonzalez must exhaust administrative remedies before the Board of Immigration Appeals.
- Individualized bond hearings resulting in flight-risk findings defeat claims of arbitrary prolonged detention where the petitioner fails to challenge those findings administratively.
- Prudential administrative exhaustion under 28 U.S.C. § 2241 is strictly enforced to utilize agency expertise, facilitate internal error correction, and prevent deliberate bypass of administrative review.
Why It Matters
This decision reinforces Ninth Circuit precedent strictly limiting 8 U.S.C. § 1252(g) to three specific statutory actions, preserving federal habeas jurisdiction to review bond proceedings independent of removal. Simultaneously, the ruling highlights that constitutional challenges attacking underlying competency findings in bond proceedings remain subject to prudential exhaustion before the Board of Immigration Appeals.
Detainees cannot circumvent agency review simply by framing evidentiary disputes regarding competency evaluations as constitutional due process claims.