Unreported / Non-Citable
Background
Petitioner, a native and citizen of Venezuela seeking asylum, presented at a Texas port of entry in August 2024 with a scheduled CBP appointment and was granted humanitarian parole into the United States pending removal proceedings through August 2026. Following his release, he lived in Daly City, California, where he worked and supported his family, including a newborn child who required intensive care.
In February 2026, Petitioner was arrested in San Mateo County, eventually pleading no contest in May 2026 to misdemeanor assault under California Penal Code § 240 in exchange for probation, credit for time served, and a work program that he completed in August 2026. In October 2026, ICE arrested Petitioner outside his residence based on his criminal history and re-detained him without providing an immigration bond hearing. Petitioner filed a petition for a writ of habeas corpus under 28 U.S.C. § 2241 alongside a motion for a temporary restraining order seeking immediate release.
Respondents argued that Petitioner was subject to mandatory detention under 8 U.S.C. § 1225(b)(2)(A) as an applicant for admission and lacked constitutional rights against continued detention beyond statutory entitlements. Respondents also pointed to his criminal history as justifying his detention.
The Court’s Holding
The District Court granted the habeas petition in part and denied the motion for a temporary restraining order as moot. Assuming without deciding that 8 U.S.C. § 1225(b) governed, the court held that under the Mathews v. Eldridge due process balancing framework, Petitioner’s continued physical confinement following more than two years of community life and the expiration of parole required an individualized custody determination by a neutral adjudicator.
Applying Ninth Circuit precedent, the court determined that the government must provide an individualized bond hearing before an immigration judge within fourteen days. At that hearing, the government must prove by clear and convincing evidence that Petitioner presents a flight risk or a danger to the community to justify continued detention without bond, with the immigration judge required to consider financial circumstances and alternative release conditions. If the hearing is not provided within fourteen days, Respondents must immediately release him.
Key Takeaways
- A noncitizen's protected liberty interest established by living in the community does not automatically expire alongside the formal expiration of humanitarian parole.
- Due process requires an individualized bond hearing before a neutral decisionmaker when the government re-detains an individual after years of community release.
- At the required bond hearing, the government carries the burden of establishing flight risk or community danger by clear and convincing evidence.
- Discrepancies in government accounts of criminal records demonstrate the necessity of neutral evidentiary testing rather than unilateral agency assertions of danger.
Why It Matters
The decision reinforces emerging Ninth Circuit and district court precedent that distinguishes admission rights from detention safeguards, confirming that individuals previously paroled into the country retain constitutional liberty interests that require robust procedural protections prior to sustained re-incarceration.
By requiring clear and convincing evidence from the government and mandating consideration of ability to pay and non-monetary alternatives, the ruling limits the executive branch's capacity to unilaterally re-detain paroled noncitizens under mandatory detention statutes without prompt judicial or quasi-judicial review.