Unreported / Non-Citable
Background
Petitioner Antonio Correa Ventosilla, an immigration detainee awaiting removal proceedings, filed a habeas petition and motion for temporary restraining order alleging that his re-detention without notice or a pre-deprivation hearing violated his Fifth Amendment due process rights. The Court agreed and ordered his immediate release.
The Court found that Petitioner entered the United States in July 2022, was released on his own recognizance with electronic monitoring under the Alternative to Detention Program, was later placed in removal proceedings, and was re-detained in June 2026. At an August 2026 bond hearing, the immigration judge found that it lacked jurisdiction to grant bond because Petitioner was mandatorily detained under 8 U.S.C. § 1225(b)(2), and Respondents' records showed no criminal history.
After setting a briefing schedule and issuing an order to show cause citing its prior decisions in Avila and Kumar, the Court considered Respondents' argument that this case was distinguishable because Petitioner allegedly violated parole conditions and received an individualized bond hearing. The Court rejected both arguments.
The Court’s Holding
Applying Mathews v. Eldridge, the Court held that Petitioner had a substantial liberty interest in remaining out of custody after his release, the risk of erroneous deprivation without notice and an individualized hearing was considerable, and the Government's interest in withholding minimal procedural safeguards was low. Whether or not the alleged parole violations occurred, Petitioner was entitled to notice and an opportunity to dispute revocation before or promptly after detention; the absence of that process suggested the violations were a pretextual basis for detention.
The later bond hearing did not cure the violation because the immigration judge did not consider the alleged parole violations or flight risk and instead found that it lacked jurisdiction to grant bond under § 1225(b)(2). The Court held that this misapplied Rodriguez Vazquez v. Bostock, under which noncitizens apprehended in the interior are subject to discretionary detention under § 1226, requiring an individualized assessment rather than mandatory detention.
Key Takeaways
- A noncitizen released from immigration custody on his own recognizance has a protected liberty interest in remaining out of custody, triggering due process protection before revocation of that release.
- Notice of alleged parole violations and an opportunity to contest revocation must be provided before or promptly after re-detention, regardless of whether the violations ultimately occurred.
- A later bond hearing that rests on a mistaken mandatory-detention theory under § 1225(b)(2), rather than an individualized assessment under § 1226, does not cure the earlier due process violation.
- The permanent injunction requires pre-deprivation notice of changed circumstances and a timely hearing at which the Government bears a clear-and-convincing burden to show danger or flight risk, with counsel present.
Why It Matters
This order extends the Court's approach in Avila and Kumar to a detainee accused of parole violations, holding that alleged violations do not eliminate the right to notice and a prompt opportunity to be heard before revocation of conditional release.
The decision also reinforces Rodriguez Vazquez v. Bostock by holding that an immigration judge's reliance on mandatory detention under § 1225(b)(2) for an interior apprehension cannot substitute for the individualized assessment required under § 1226. The Court expressly left open detention upon an executable final removal order or in exigent circumstances.