Unreported / Non-Citable
Background
320 Alemany LLC constructed 15 permitted residential units across four San Francisco lots between 2004 and 2008, but shortly thereafter partitioned the properties to create 17 additional unpermitted dwelling units. Following a 2022 city inspection revealing safety hazards, the City filed an enforcement action in 2023. On April 15, 2024, the parties stipulated to an injunction and order (dated April 9, 2024) requiring the owner to bring the buildings into code compliance, obtain all necessary permits, and pay approximately $1.5 million in penalties and fees.
While addressing the violations, the owner sought to legalize the unauthorized units under California's density bonus law (Gov. Code, § 65915), submitting a proposal to authorize 31 total units. The planning department and zoning administrator determined the project was ineligible because it did not add at least five base units, and the Board of Appeals affirmed. The owner then petitioned for a writ of administrative mandamus, which the trial court denied.
The Court’s Holding
The First District Court of Appeal affirmed, holding that the density bonus law does not apply retroactively to legalize dwelling units built without permits. Under Government Code section 65915, subdivision (b)(1), an applicant must seek and agree to construct a housing development containing the required affordable-housing set-aside. Because the owner proposed no new construction and merely sought to legalize existing unauthorized units, its proposal did not qualify as a housing development under the statute.
The court also rejected the claim that the project qualified under section 65915, subdivision (i) as a substantial rehabilitation of a multifamily dwelling resulting in a net increase in available units. Assuming without deciding that the rehabilitation clause is not limited to subdivisions or common interest developments, the court concluded that work limited to legalizing unpermitted units, verifying systems, replacing wallboard and windows, and adding a roof deck did not constitute substantial rehabilitation. The court also rejected the owner's preemption claim for failure to identify any conflicting local ordinance.
Key Takeaways
- California's density bonus law (Gov. Code, § 65915) applies prospectively to incentivize new construction and cannot be invoked retroactively to legalize unpermitted dwelling units.
- To obtain a density bonus under section 65915, subdivision (b)(1), a developer must agree to construct five or more base units with the required proportion of affordable housing.
- Work consisting of legalizing unauthorized units, verifying utilities, and making minor cosmetic repairs does not constitute 'substantial rehabilitation' producing net new units under section 65915, subdivision (i).
- A developer cannot establish state-law preemption without identifying a specific local ordinance that conflicts with the governing state enactment.
- Appellate courts reviewing administrative mandamus decisions generally decline to take judicial notice of local enactments not presented to the trial court.
Why It Matters
This decision confirms that California's density bonus law functions strictly as a prospective development incentive rather than a retroactive amnesty mechanism for unauthorized construction. It provides municipalities with firm statutory authority to deny density bonuses to owners seeking to legalize existing unpermitted units without constructing new housing.
The ruling also highlights and preserves an open question under section 65915, subdivision (i)—whether the substantial-rehabilitation pathway is available only to subdivisions and common interest developments—while underscoring that routine code-compliance repairs cannot satisfy the statute's substantial-rehabilitation threshold.