Unreported / Non-Citable
Background
The complaint alleges an Americans with Disabilities Act claim seeking injunctive relief and a California Unruh Civil Rights Act claim seeking damages. The plaintiff asked the court to exercise supplemental jurisdiction over the state-law claim under 28 U.S.C. § 1367.
Judge Fernando L. Aenlle-Rocha explained that supplemental jurisdiction is discretionary and that § 1367(c) lists grounds for declining it, including novel state-law issues, predominance of state claims, dismissal of all federal claims, and exceptional circumstances. The court also noted California's heightened pleading rules for construction-accessibility claims and its high-frequency litigant fee, citing Schutza v. Cuddeback as an example of courts declining jurisdiction as a matter of comity.
The Court’s Holding
The court did not decide whether to exercise supplemental jurisdiction. Instead, it ordered the plaintiff to show cause in writing why the court should retain the Unruh Act claim and any related state-law claims.
The response must identify the amount of statutory damages sought and be supported by declarations, signed under penalty of perjury, addressing whether the plaintiff and counsel qualify as a 'high-frequency litigant' under California Code of Civil Procedure § 425.55(b)(1) and (2). The response is due within fourteen days, and failure to respond adequately may result in declining supplemental jurisdiction and dismissing the state-law claims without further notice.
Key Takeaways
- Supplemental jurisdiction under 28 U.S.C. § 1367 is discretionary, and courts may decline it for the reasons listed in § 1367(c).
- California's heightened pleading requirements and high-frequency litigant fee for disability-access cases can weigh against federal courts exercising supplemental jurisdiction over Unruh Act claims as a matter of comity.
- A plaintiff seeking supplemental jurisdiction over an Unruh Act claim may be required to disclose the statutory damages sought and to submit sworn declarations addressing high-frequency litigant status.
- Failure to respond adequately to this order to show cause may result in dismissal of the state-law claims without further notice.
Why It Matters
This order illustrates how federal courts may scrutinize supplemental jurisdiction over California disability-access claims at an early stage, using an order to show cause rather than deciding the issue outright.
The required damages disclosure and sworn high-frequency-litigant declarations give the court a record for evaluating comity, fairness, and California's interest in curbing abusive accessibility litigation before deciding whether to retain the state-law claims.