California Case Summaries

Robert Brian Parker v. Banks of California — Court Orders Pro Se Plaintiff to Show Cause on Jurisdiction and Claims, Denies Counsel Request as Premature

Unreported / Non-Citable

Case
Robert Brian Parker v. Banks of California
Court
U.S. District Court — Southern District of California
Judge
Cathy Ann Bencivengo (Barack Obama, 2012)
Date Decided
2026-11-19
Docket No.
3:26-cv-04986
Status
Unreported
Topics
subject matter jurisdiction, pro se litigation, appointment of counsel, show cause order, screening

Background

Robert Brian Parker, proceeding pro se, filed a complaint on September 2, 2026 against the “Banks of California,” which his Civil Cover Sheet appeared to identify as Wells Fargo Bank of San Diego and US Bank of San Diego. The cover sheet invoked federal-question jurisdiction but listed only “CA Civ Pro Code & 1530 (2025)” as a cause of action, while the complaint itself asserted no cause of action at all.

On November 4, 2026, Parker moved for appointment of pro bono counsel. The court applied the Ninth Circuit standard requiring exceptional circumstances, considering both likelihood of success on the merits and whether the litigant can articulate his claims given the complexity of the issues.

The Court’s Holding

The court found it could not evaluate Parker's likelihood of success or ability to articulate claims because the complaint failed to identify any cause of action or basis for federal jurisdiction. It also held that the case was at too early a stage for those determinations.

The court ordered Parker to show cause by December 21, 2026 why the court has subject-matter jurisdiction and to specify the causes of action he is pursuing, warning that failure to respond timely would result in dismissal. The motion to appoint counsel was denied without prejudice, with leave to renew if Parker could make the required showing.

Key Takeaways

  • A pro se complaint that asserts no cause of action and no apparent basis for federal jurisdiction will draw an order to show cause on subject-matter jurisdiction rather than immediate dismissal.
  • There is no absolute right to appointed counsel in a civil case; appointment requires exceptional circumstances, including likelihood of success and inability to present claims competently.
  • A counsel request can be denied as premature when the pleadings are too undeveloped to assess either merits or the litigant's presentation abilities.
  • The denial was without prejudice, so the plaintiff may renew the request if circumstances change and he can satisfy the Ninth Circuit standard.

Why It Matters

This order illustrates early screening of a deficient pro se complaint: instead of dismissing outright, the court required the plaintiff to identify both a jurisdictional basis and actual causes of action, with dismissal as the stated consequence of noncompliance.

The ruling also confirms that appointment of counsel depends on a developed record; where the complaint itself is unintelligible as to claims, the court cannot find the exceptional circumstances needed to appoint counsel.

Read the full opinion (PDF) · Court docket

Scroll to Top