Unreported / Non-Citable
Background
Manochehr “Mike” Nazarian and Westside Lighting, Inc. partnered with Aaron Green on commercial lighting rebate projects, providing capital based on weekly spreadsheets provided by Green. Green directed payments to purported vendor accounts that were actually fictitious or owned by EOS Organization, LLC, an entity Green controlled and concealed from Nazarian, allowing Green to divert the money to his personal accounts.
Westside later signed a written partnership agreement with Direct Green Solutions, LLC (DGS), an unformed entity signed for by Green. After receiving no returns, respondents sued Green, DGS, EOS, and Lux Technology Group, Inc. for fraud, conversion, and civil theft under Penal Code section 496, subdivision (c). Following a bench trial, the Los Angeles County Superior Court entered a joint and several judgment exceeding $10 million against all defendants as alter egos, trebling the primary damages under section 496. The court struck Lux's answer because its corporate status was suspended by the Franchise Tax Board.
The Court’s Holding
The Court of Appeal dismissed Lux's appeal and affirmed the judgment as to Green, DGS, and EOS. Under Revenue and Taxation Code section 23301, a corporation suspended for failure to pay taxes lacks legal capacity to prosecute an appeal from an adverse judgment.
On the civil theft claim under Penal Code section 496, the appellate court held that the trial court properly made ultimate findings of specific intent to permanently deprive and knowing misrepresentation, without needing transaction-by-transaction findings. Appellants forfeited their one-year statute of limitations defense because, although pleaded in their answer, they abandoned it at trial without trying factual issues of concealment and tolling.
Contract arguments regarding expense offsets and integration did not affect the judgment, which rested independently on tort and statutory theft. Finally, outside reverse veil piercing is legally available against limited liability companies under California law; appellants forfeited their factual challenges regarding EOS's minority investors and alternative legal remedies by failing to raise them in the trial court.
Key Takeaways
- A corporation suspended by the Franchise Tax Board under Revenue and Taxation Code section 23301 lacks the capacity to maintain an appeal, warranting dismissal.
- Treble damages under Penal Code section 496 require only ultimate findings of knowing misrepresentation and felonious intent, not separate findings for each payment.
- An affirmative defense pleaded in an answer is forfeited if the defendant fails to litigate and prove the underlying facts at trial.
- Outside reverse veil piercing applies to limited liability companies, and equitable arguments protecting minority member interests are forfeited if omitted at trial.
Why It Matters
This decision confirms that civil theft treble damages under Penal Code section 496, subdivision (c) reach commercial fraudulent schemes where funds are diverted through concealed alter-ego entities, regardless of subsequent spending on project expenses. It also establishes that outside reverse veil piercing applies to limited liability companies under California law, while emphasizing that equitable defenses concerning minority members must be developed at trial to avoid forfeiture on appeal.