Unreported / Non-Citable
Background
American Business Bank entered into a Business Loan Agreement and an associated two million dollar line of credit with Los Angeles Produce Distributors, LLC (LA Produce), guaranteed by Matthew Clark and others. After the credit facility matured on January 15, 2025, without full repayment, the bank filed a breach of contract action in Los Angeles County Superior Court against LA Produce and the guarantors. Under California's Attachment Law (Code Civ. Proc. § 482.010 et seq.), the bank applied for right to attach orders and writs of attachment, supported by declarations and loan records establishing the default.
LA Produce and Clark opposed attachment, submitting a declaration from Clark asserting 'lender liability' affirmative defenses. Clark claimed the bank negligently misrepresented that it would work out the debt without litigation and improperly interfered with LA Produce's management of subsidiary LAP Fresh. Appellants argued that because the bank offered no evidence rebutting Clark's declaration, it failed to show the probable validity of its claims. The trial court granted the bank's applications, concluding the defenses were legally and factually unsupported.
The Court’s Holding
The California Court of Appeal, Second Appellate District, Division Five, affirmed the right to attach order and writs of attachment. Reviewing under the substantial evidence standard, the court held that the trial court was not required to accept Clark's sworn assertions as true merely because the bank offered no direct rebuttal evidence. Clark's declaration offered only vague, conclusory impressions rather than competent evidence demonstrating improper lender interference or actionable misconduct.
The court further held that appellants' affirmative defenses failed as a matter of law to undermine probable validity or justify an offset under Code of Civil Procedure section 483.015. Negligent misrepresentation requires a false statement of past or existing fact and cannot be predicated on broken promises regarding future workout negotiations. In addition, speculative assertions that the bank aided and abetted third-party wrongdoing at an affiliated entity did not diminish the validity or amount of the bank's contract claim.
Key Takeaways
- A plaintiff seeking a prejudgment right to attach order is not required to submit rebuttal evidence where the defendant's declarations fail to establish a prima facie factual defense.
- Trial courts evaluating probable validity under California's Attachment Law are not obligated to accept uncorroborated, conclusory declarations as true, even if uncontradicted by opposing affidavits.
- Promises of future workout negotiations or forbearance cannot support an affirmative defense of negligent misrepresentation, which requires a misstatement of existing or past fact.
- To reduce or offset an attachment amount under Code of Civil Procedure section 483.015, the defending party must establish a viable prima facie claim or defense on which an attachment could issue.
Why It Matters
This decision confirms that commercial lenders seeking prejudgment attachment under California law need not affirmatively disprove legally defective or speculative borrower defenses. By affirming that trial courts may evaluate declaration credibility and reject promissory tort defenses at the provisional remedy stage, the ruling prevents borrowers from delaying attachment through conclusory allegations of informal workout discussions.