California Case Summaries

Castillo Sosa v. Blanche — Substantial Evidence Supports Denial of Asylum, Withholding, and CAT Protection Where Harassment Stemmed from Investigation and Relocation Mitigates Future Torture Risk

Unreported / Non-Citable

Case
Castillo Sosa v. Blanche
Court
Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals
Judge
Hawkins (William J. Clinton, 1994); Wardlaw (Bill Clinton, 1998); Hurwitz (Barack Obama, 2012)
Date Decided
2026-11-19
Docket No.
25-5791
Status
Unreported
Topics
Immigration Law, Asylum, Withholding of Removal, Convention Against Torture, Nexus Requirement, Internal Relocation

Background

Rixi Danuris Castillo-Sosa and her minor daughter, natives and citizens of Honduras, petitioned for review of a decision of the Board of Immigration Appeals (BIA) dismissing their appeal from an Immigration Judge's (IJ) order denying their applications for asylum, withholding of removal, and protection under the Convention Against Torture (CAT). Castillo-Sosa's daughter sought asylum as a derivative beneficiary and also filed her own applications based on the same assertions.

Before the agency, Castillo asserted that after her former partner's brother was murdered, she asked the police for an investigation, which triggered a campaign of threats, a physical beating of her former partner, and her rape by perpetrators she believed were police officers. The agency found that the perpetrators acted to stop her from investigating the murder rather than on account of a protected social group or an imputed political opinion, and further determined that she had not shown it was more likely than not that she would face future torture upon return to Honduras.

The Court’s Holding

The Ninth Circuit denied the petitions for review. Reviewing for substantial evidence, the panel held that the record supported the agency's conclusion that Castillo failed to establish the requisite nexus between past or feared harm and a protected ground, as the abusers acted to halt her investigation into the murder rather than targeting her on account of a protected characteristic or imputed political opinion.

The panel also held that substantial evidence supported the denial of CAT relief because past torture does not create a presumption of future torture and the agency reasonably assessed the viability of internal relocation. Although police officers inquired about Castillo after her departure, those inquiries ceased in 2019 once her relatives relocated to another department within Honduras, where they lived without incident for at least four years. Finally, the panel rejected the contention that the BIA engaged in improper factfinding, observing that the Board relied solely on the IJ's findings.

Judge Wardlaw concurred in part and dissented in part. While concurring in the denial of asylum and withholding of removal, Judge Wardlaw concluded that the record compelled the granting of CAT relief because Castillo suffered past torture via rape by police officers and the evidence demonstrated that centralized Honduran police forces would easily locate and target her if returned.

Key Takeaways

  • An applicant for asylum or withholding of removal must establish that persecution occurred on account of a protected ground rather than solely to deter a private or criminal investigation.
  • Under Ninth Circuit precedent, past torture is relevant to CAT claims but creates no mandatory presumption of future torture.
  • Evidence showing that family members relocated within the home country and lived for multiple years without renewed police contact or harassment provides substantial evidence supporting agency findings on internal relocation feasibility.
  • The BIA does not engage in improper independent factfinding when it confines its decision to adopting and reviewing the findings made by the Immigration Judge.

Why It Matters

This decision illustrates the stringent standard of review applied to agency nexus and CAT determinations, underscoring that evidence of horrific past abuse will not overcome an adverse ruling where the record permits a reasonable finding that the abuse was non-nexus retaliation and that changed circumstances or internal relocation undermine the likelihood of future torture.

Judge Wardlaw's partial dissent highlights an ongoing division regarding the practical safety of internal relocation in countries with centralized national police forces implicated in severe human rights violations.

Read the full opinion (PDF) · Court docket

Scroll to Top