California Case Summaries

Atiyeh v. American Business Bank — Court of Appeal Affirms Vexatious Litigant Designation and Prefiling Order Against Pro Per Borrowers

Unreported / Non-Citable

Case
Atiyeh v. American Business Bank
Court
4th District Court of Appeal, Division Three
Judge
Gooding (Gavin Newsom, 2023); Moore (Gray Davis, 2000); Scott (Gavin Newsom, 2025)
Date Decided
2026-11-19
Docket No.
G065971
Status
Unreported / Non-Citable
Topics
vexatious litigants, prefiling orders, security requirement, forfeiture on appeal, judicial assignment, nonjudicial foreclosure

Background

In December 2024, pro per plaintiffs Lannette Atiyeh and Andy Atiyeh filed an action against American Business Bank arising from a nonjudicial foreclosure dispute over their residence. In April 2025, the bank moved to declare plaintiffs vexatious litigants, require $25,000 in security, and obtain a prefiling order under Code of Civil Procedure sections 391, 391.3, and 391.7. Plaintiffs did not file an opposition or include the underlying motion papers in the appellate record.

Following a September 8, 2025 hearing attended only by the bank, Orange County Superior Court Judge Richard J. Oberholzer—a retired Kern County Superior Court judge sitting by assignment—granted the motion under section 391, subdivisions (b)(2) and (b)(3), ordered $25,000 in security, and issued a prefiling order. The court then denied plaintiffs' ex parte application to vacate the orders, rejecting their claim that Judge Oberholzer lacked jurisdiction without a party stipulation under California Constitution article VI, section 21. Plaintiffs appealed.

The Court’s Holding

The Fourth District Court of Appeal, Division Three, affirmed. The court held that plaintiffs forfeited any challenge to their vexatious litigant designation under section 391, subdivision (b)(2), because their appellate briefs addressed only subdivision (b)(3) and offered no reasoned argument or authority regarding subdivision (b)(2). Because subdivision (b)(2) independently supported the vexatious litigant finding, the court did not need to review the findings under subdivision (b)(3).

The appellate court rejected plaintiffs' jurisdictional challenge, determining that Judge Oberholzer was assigned by the Chief Justice under article VI, section 6 of the California Constitution, rather than serving as a temporary judge under article VI, section 21. Retired judges sitting by assignment possess full judicial authority without party consent. Because plaintiffs failed to provide a reporter's transcript or settled statement, the court applied the presumption that official judicial duties were regularly performed.

The court also held that another judge's denial of a vexatious litigant motion against a different entity in a separate proceeding did not preclude relief here. Furthermore, plaintiffs forfeited their due process claims regarding the lack of opportunity to oppose the motion by failing to develop reasoned arguments, and prefiling orders under section 391.7 constitutionally restrict only meritless litigation without denying access to the courts.

Key Takeaways

  • Failing to challenge an independent statutory ground for a vexatious litigant finding on appeal forfeits the claim and requires affirmance.
  • Retired judges assigned by the Chief Justice under article VI, section 6 of the California Constitution possess full judicial authority and do not require party stipulations.
  • Appellants who fail to furnish an adequate record, such as a reporter's transcript or settled statement, cannot overcome the presumption of correctness.
  • A prior trial court order denying a vexatious litigant motion against a distinct entity in a separate action does not bar a vexatious litigant designation.

Why It Matters

This decision illustrates the strict enforcement of appellate forfeiture when a trial court's vexatious litigant order rests on alternative statutory grounds under Code of Civil Procedure section 391. It also clarifies that retired judges sitting by assignment pursuant to article VI, section 6 of the California Constitution exercise valid judicial authority without the party stipulations required for temporary judges under section 21.

Read the full opinion (PDF) · Court docket

Scroll to Top