Unreported / Non-Citable
Background
Plaintiff Jeffrey S. Nedd, a California state prisoner proceeding pro se and in forma pauperis, initiated a civil rights action pursuant to 42 U.S.C. § 1983 seeking post-conviction DNA testing under California Penal Code § 1405 and Skinner v. Switzer. After his first amended complaint was screened and dismissed with leave to amend, Plaintiff filed a second amended complaint naming prosecutor Kelly Smith as the sole defendant.
In his operative pleading, Plaintiff claimed actual innocence regarding a rape conviction, asserting that DNA testing of a rape kit would demonstrate he was not the perpetrator and arguing that his appointed counsel failed to file a declaration seeking testing. The magistrate judge screened the complaint pursuant to 28 U.S.C. § 1915A to determine whether it stated a plausible claim for relief against the governmental defendant.
The Court’s Holding
The magistrate judge concluded that the second amended complaint failed to satisfy Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 8 and failed to state a cognizable § 1983 claim. Although Skinner v. Switzer allows procedural due process challenges to state DNA access statutes, Plaintiff did not challenge California Penal Code § 1405 either facially or as applied, instead contesting his defense counsel's decision not to file a testing motion and challenging the validity of his confinement, which lies exclusively within habeas corpus.
The court further determined that Defendant Kelly Smith was entitled to absolute prosecutorial immunity for conduct intimately associated with the judicial phase of the criminal process. Moreover, the magistrate judge held that the suit was barred by claim preclusion because Plaintiff had litigated the identical transactional nucleus of facts against the same defendant in an earlier federal action that was dismissed on the merits for failure to state a claim.
Key Takeaways
- Section 1983 actions seeking post-conviction DNA testing under Skinner v. Switzer must challenge the constitutionality of the governing state statute facially or as applied, rather than disputing defense counsel's strategic choice not to seek testing.
- State prosecutors enjoy absolute immunity under § 1983 when responding to or handling post-conviction requests for DNA testing within the judicial phase.
- Dismissal of an earlier prisoner civil rights action for failure to state a claim constitutes a final judgment on the merits that bars duplicative subsequent lawsuits under claim preclusion principles.
- Challenges effectively disputing the validity of an underlying criminal conviction or confinement remain exclusive to federal habeas corpus proceedings rather than § 1983 actions.
Why It Matters
The findings and recommendations reinforce strict adherence to the boundaries established by Skinner v. Switzer, highlighting that federal civil rights actions cannot serve as an end-run around state post-conviction DNA procedures or ordinary habeas avenues without a direct constitutional challenge to the state statute.
The ruling also exemplifies the Eastern District of California's rigorous application of sua sponte claim preclusion during 28 U.S.C. § 1915A screening to prevent repetitive, vexatious litigation by state prisoners.