Unreported / Non-Citable
Background
Billy Driver, Jr., a prisoner proceeding pro se, sued Schultz and other defendants in the Eastern District of California under 42 U.S.C. § 1983 (No. 2:25-cv-1723-DC-ICD). The magistrate judge described the action as concerning Driver's claims of denial of protection in a state correctional facility, citing ECF No. 13. A settlement conference before Judge Kim is set for February 24, 2027.
Two filings, ECF Nos. 28 and 29, were construed as motions for injunctive relief. In ECF No. 28, Driver wrote that he could not receive his legal books and property from California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation officials. The court noted that he complained of restricted access to legal materials at Coalinga State Hospital, feared missing deadlines, and asked for no specific relief. In ECF No. 29, he asked the court to order the defendant to settle and to rule on a summary judgment motion that is not currently before the court.
The Court’s Holding
Magistrate Judge Ila C. Deiss issued findings and recommendations, dated November 16, 2026, that both motions be denied. The judge set out the Winter test and the Ninth Circuit's alternative serious-questions standard. The judge also applied the requirement of a nexus between the motion and the underlying complaint, the rule that courts cannot issue orders against non-parties, and the Prison Litigation Reform Act's requirement that prison-condition injunctions be narrowly drawn.
On ECF No. 28, the court found that the complaint about legal materials at Coalinga State Hospital does not seek injunctive relief against any party to this action. It also found no nexus between that complaint and the underlying claims. Driver also showed no irreparable injury, because any effect on case deadlines could be addressed by requests for extensions of time or a stipulation with opposing counsel.
On ECF No. 29, the court treated the request to order settlement as a mandatory injunction carrying a doubly demanding burden. Because a settlement conference is already scheduled, it found that Driver could not clearly show that the law and facts favored an order to settle before that conference. The court declined to rule on the summary judgment motion because it is not before the court.
These are recommendations to the assigned district judge, not a final ruling. Parties have 14 days after service to file objections, and responses are due 14 days after objections are served. Failure to object may waive the right to appeal.
Key Takeaways
- A motion for injunctive relief must connect to the claims in the underlying complaint, so a grievance about legal materials at a different institution did not fit this case.
- An injunction request must be directed at parties to the action, and the property-access motion sought no relief against any party.
- Concern about missing case deadlines is not irreparable injury when extension requests or stipulations are available.
- A request to order defendants to settle is a mandatory injunction that must clearly be supported by the law and facts, and the magistrate judge found it was not.
- The recommendations await review by the district judge after the objection period, and the settlement conference remains scheduled.
Why It Matters
The findings show how a magistrate judge screens a prisoner's injunction requests that fall outside the claims in a pending § 1983 case. They keep unrelated custodial complaints separate from the existing litigation and point the plaintiff to ordinary case-management tools for scheduling concerns.
They also show that an order compelling settlement faces the heightened standard for mandatory injunctions, particularly where a settlement conference is already set.