Reported / Citable
Background
S.N. sued Fresno Unified School District under former Code of Civil Procedure section 340.1, alleging teacher Maximo Parayno III sexually abused her in 2001 while she was a fifth-grade student. Her first amended complaint asserted negligence and negligent hiring, retention, and supervision, alleging District knew Parayno posed a danger, settled a 1999 molestation suit against him, and left him in the classroom with unsupervised access to students.
District moved for summary judgment solely on statutory immunity under Education Code section 44808, asserting S.N.'s deposition established that all alleged abuse occurred off campus and after school hours. The trial court granted summary judgment, excluded S.N.'s notice evidence on hearsay and authentication grounds, and refused to consider an authenticated police report and declaration filed on the hearing date. Judgment was entered October 3, 2025.
The Court’s Holding
The Court of Appeal reversed, holding that section 44808's reasonable care clause is an independent exception to immunity, linked to other exceptions by the disjunctive "or." Adopting the reasoning of Justice Raphael's concurrence in Victor Valley Union High School Dist. v. Superior Court, the court held the clause preserves liability for a district's own negligence—including negligent hiring, retention, supervision, and procedures—regardless of where the injury occurs.
Because District's motion addressed only the location and timing of the abuse, not whether District exercised reasonable care or whether its breach caused S.N.'s injuries, District failed to satisfy its initial burden of production, and the burden never shifted to S.N. The court declined to follow decisions treating injury location as controlling, including Mosley and Taylor, and remanded without deciding the admissibility of S.N.'s evidence.
Key Takeaways
- Education Code section 44808's reasonable care clause is an independent exception to school district immunity, not a standard of care qualifying specific undertakings.
- A school district cannot obtain summary judgment under section 44808 merely by proving that the alleged abuse occurred off campus and outside school hours.
- When a complaint alleges a district's own supervisory negligence caused student injury, the district bears the initial burden to negate the reasonable care exception.
- The court rejected decisions such as Mosley and Taylor that treat the location of the student's injury as dispositive under section 44808.
- The admissibility of the plaintiff's notice and police report evidence was not resolved on appeal and remains open for determination on remand.
Why It Matters
This published opinion adopts Justice Raphael's Victor Valley concurrence, creating a split with decisions that limit the reasonable care clause to enumerated undertakings. Although the California Supreme Court granted review in Victor Valley on an on-premises negligence question, the Fifth District established that liability under the reasonable care clause does not depend on where negligence occurred.
The decision significantly restricts statutory immunity for school districts facing negligent hiring, supervision, or retention claims, ensuring districts cannot defeat tort suits on summary judgment without affirmatively proving reasonable care.