California Case Summaries

Clark v. Cephus — Affirmance of dismissal without prejudice for failure to serve defendants within two years

Unreported / Non-Citable

Case
Clark v. Cephus
Court
2nd District Court of Appeal
Judge
Tamzarian; Zukin; Daum
Date Decided
2026-11-18
Docket No.
B352567
Status
Unreported / Non-Citable
Topics
service of process, service by publication, dismissal for failure to serve, abuse of discretion, appellate record, unpublished opinion

Background

Daveon Clark filed this action on November 7, 2023. Cephus moved to quash purported substituted service made by leaving papers with his brother at his mother's house in Georgia, and the trial court granted the motion on July 18, 2024, finding Clark failed to show the address was Cephus's usual mailing address. The court also noted that Clark's attorney did not explain why he was attempting to serve a former management company for Cephus in Woodland Hills before the purported substituted service.

Clark twice applied for orders authorizing service on Cephus by publication. The first application was denied for insufficient showing of due diligence; the opinion does not specify the ground for the second denial. He also claimed applications as to Carter were denied, but those documents were not in the appellate record.

At a November 17, 2025 hearing on an order to show cause re failure to file proof of service, with no reporter present, the court ordered the complaint dismissed without prejudice. The signed order of dismissal was file stamped April 17, 2026, and the Court of Appeal treated the premature appeal as challenging that order.

The Court’s Holding

The Court of Appeal applied abuse-of-discretion review to both the denial of service by publication and the dismissal for failure to serve within two years, and found no clear or manifest abuse of discretion.

Clark's unsupported assertions about extensive service attempts were not cited to the record in his argument section, and he did not differentiate between attempts to serve Cephus and Carter. As to Carter, neither the publication application nor the denial was in the record. Clark also failed to address the second statutory requirement for service by publication—that a cause of action exists against the party or the party has or claims an interest in property in this state—and the complaint itself was absent from the record.

Even excluding the period when Cephus contested service, the action was not dismissed until more than two years after filing. The record did not indicate whether Clark's exclusion arguments were made below or the trial court's reasoning, and no reporter was present at the OSC hearing. Clark did not establish that the dismissal exceeded all bounds of reason.

Key Takeaways

  • An appellant challenging denial of service by publication and dismissal for failure to serve must support argument-section assertions with record citations; vague descriptions of diligence efforts will not carry the burden.
  • An incomplete record—including missing applications, denials, and the complaint—requires resolution of the affected issues against the appellant.
  • Even excluding time spent litigating validity of service, dismissal without prejudice was proper where more than two years elapsed before dismissal and no transcript showed the trial court's reasoning.
  • Citing an unpublished California Court of Appeal opinion is improper under California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a).

Why It Matters

This unpublished opinion reinforces the deferential abuse-of-discretion standard governing dismissals for failure to serve within two years and the strict record-citation requirements on appeal.

It also illustrates how missing transcripts and documents can independently defeat claims of trial court error in service and dismissal rulings.

Read the full opinion (PDF) · Court docket

Scroll to Top