Unreported / Non-Citable
Background
In September 2021, Huan Liu agreed to purchase real property from Beverly Flaum and deposited $36,000 into escrow with Fidelity National Title Company. When the purchase failed to close, the escrow instructions required mutually signed written release instructions to disburse the deposit. Flaum signed a proposed mutual cancellation form, but Liu refused, contending the underlying purchase contract remained operative.
Facing conflicting duties without joint instructions, Fidelity filed an interpleader action under Code of Civil Procedure section 386 in August 2022 and deposited the $36,000 with the court. After difficulty serving the bedridden Flaum, Fidelity moved for discharge in October 2023, which the court denied without prejudice in March 2024 because Flaum's default had not been taken. Flaum died, prompting Fidelity to amend its complaint to name her heirs, obtain a disclaimer from her son, and take her daughter's default. Following denials of Liu's motion for judgment on the pleadings and motion to dismiss for dilatory prosecution, Fidelity filed a second discharge motion in September 2025. In February 2026, the trial court granted discharge, dismissed Fidelity, awarded it $12,000 in attorney fees under section 386.6 from the deposit, and ordered the remainder released to Liu.
The Court’s Holding
The California Court of Appeal, First Appellate District, Division Four, affirmed. The court held that interpleader under Code of Civil Procedure section 386, subdivision (b) does not require active, competing ownership claims to deposited funds. Instead, interpleader lies whenever a stakeholder faces potential double or multiple liability, or conflicting duties, regarding the property. Because Fidelity faced liability if it released funds without joint instructions or if Flaum's estate claimed forfeiture, interpleader was proper.
The court further held that a stakeholder's right to interpleader does not fail simply because a defendant dies, defaults, disclaims interest, or fails to appear. The trial court acted within its discretion in adjudicating the discharge motion on declarations rather than requiring an evidentiary trial, and Civil Code section 1057.3, subdivision (g) expressly preserves an escrow holder's right to interplead funds during a deposit dispute. Finally, the court affirmed the denial of Liu's dilatory prosecution motion due to Fidelity's diligent service efforts, and sustained the $12,000 attorney fee award under section 386.6.
Key Takeaways
- California Code of Civil Procedure section 386, subdivision (b) authorizes interpleader whenever a stakeholder faces potential double liability or conflicting duties, not solely upon directly competing ownership claims.
- An interpleader action remains viable even if an adverse claimant subsequently dies, defaults, disclaims an interest, or fails to appear.
- Trial courts have discretion to resolve an interpleader stakeholder's discharge and dismissal on noticed motion and declarations without conducting an evidentiary trial.
- Under Civil Code section 1057.3, subdivision (g), an escrow holder retains the right to initiate interpleader when parties fail to execute mutual release instructions, and may recover reasonable attorney fees under section 386.6.
Why It Matters
This decision protects escrow holders caught in stalled real estate transactions by confirming they need not risk liability by resolving contractual disputes or determining deposit forfeiture. Where parties fail to provide joint release instructions, the escrow holder may interplead the funds, secure a discharge by motion, and recover statutory attorney fees, even if the adverse seller never appears in court to assert an affirmative claim.