Unreported / Non-Citable
Background
Petitioner Jefferson Daniel Cardona Avalos, a citizen of El Salvador, entered the United States as an unaccompanied minor in April 2021. After his initial apprehension, immigration authorities transferred him to the custody of the Office of Refugee Resettlement within the Department of Health and Human Services. In May 2021, the agency released Petitioner to the custody of his mother under the Trafficking Victims Protection Reauthorization Act. While released in the community, Petitioner applied for and received approval for both an I-360 Special Immigrant Juvenile Status petition and employment authorization from USCIS, remaining at liberty for more than five years.
Following a conviction for driving under the influence, Immigration and Customs Enforcement detained Petitioner under 8 U.S.C. § 1226(a). The agency gave him no prior notice explaining the revocation of his release and no pre-deprivation opportunity to contest his re-arrest at a hearing. Detained for several months without receiving any custody redetermination or bond hearing, Petitioner filed a federal petition for a writ of habeas corpus along with a motion for a temporary restraining order, arguing that his summary re-detention violated procedural due process under the Fifth Amendment.
The Court’s Holding
United States District Judge Noël Wise granted the habeas petition and ordered respondents to immediately release Petitioner from custody, resolving his motion for a temporary restraining order as moot. Addressing respondents' exhaustion defense first, the court waived prudential administrative exhaustion because Petitioner asserted a constitutional due process challenge to the revocation of his release, an issue beyond the administrative jurisdiction of the Board of Immigration Appeals.
On the merits, the court held that an unaccompanied minor released to a sponsor under the TVPRA acquires a constitutionally protected Fifth Amendment liberty interest in continued freedom that persists after reaching adulthood. Evaluating the claim under Mathews v. Eldridge, the court found that Petitioner's significant private interest in remaining at liberty after five years in the community, together with the high risk of erroneous deprivation where no bond hearing occurred, outweighed the government's low interest in detention without a hearing. Because the government did not demonstrate that pre-deprivation process was impracticable or would prompt flight, and kept Petitioner detained for months without any individualized determination of dangerousness or flight risk, immediate release rather than a belated post-deprivation hearing was the appropriate remedy.
Finally, the court prohibited respondents from imposing additional restrictions on Petitioner absent a determination of necessity at a future hearing. The order directed that should the government seek to re-detain Petitioner before any executable final order of removal, it must provide at least seven days' notice and conduct a pre-deprivation bond hearing before a neutral arbiter, proving dangerousness or flight risk by clear and convincing evidence.
Key Takeaways
- Noncitizens originally released as unaccompanied minors under the TVPRA maintain a protected Fifth Amendment liberty interest in continued freedom that endures into adulthood.
- Prudential administrative exhaustion is properly waived when a habeas petitioner raises a direct constitutional challenge to the revocation of release and lack of procedural protections.
- Under Mathews v. Eldridge, re-arresting a released noncitizen under 8 U.S.C. § 1226(a) without pre-deprivation process violates due process unless advance proceedings are shown to be impracticable or likely to provoke flight.
- When immigration authorities hold an individual for months without any individualized hearing, habeas relief requires immediate release rather than a remand for post-deprivation proceedings.
- Any future attempt to re-detain the petitioner absent an executable removal order requires at least seven days' notice and a pre-deprivation hearing where the government must establish flight risk or dangerousness by clear and convincing evidence.
Why It Matters
This decision adds to a consistent line of district court decisions within the Ninth Circuit restricting ICE's ability to summarily re-arrest noncitizens previously released as unaccompanied minors. By establishing that TVPRA release creates a constitutionally protected liberty interest that survives into adulthood, the ruling confirms that discretionary detention under 8 U.S.C. § 1226(a) remains subject to constitutional due process constraints.
The ruling also provides a meaningful remedial precedent by ordering direct release instead of allowing the government to cure months of unlawful detention with a belated bond hearing. Furthermore, by requiring seven days' advance notice, a pre-deprivation hearing before a neutral arbiter, and proof under the clear and convincing evidence standard, the order establishes strong procedural protections against future summary re-detention.