Unreported / Non-Citable
Background
Plaintiffs, employee benefit trust funds administered in San Francisco, filed this federal lawsuit on July 15, 2026, against defendant McGrath Electric, Inc., a California employer conducting business in the Northern District of California. Suing under Section 301 of the Labor Management Relations Act and Sections 502 and 515 of the Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974, plaintiffs sought delinquent fringe benefit contributions, statutory liquidated damages, interest, and attorney fees and costs. Plaintiffs alleged that McGrath assented to collective bargaining and trust agreements with Local 6 of the International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers, AFL-CIO, requiring monthly contribution reports and payments on or before the tenth day of each following month. Under these agreements, delinquent payments entitled plaintiffs to unpaid contributions, liquidated damages of twenty percent generally and six percent for vacation delinquencies, ten percent annual interest, and reasonable attorney fees.
The complaint alleged that McGrath failed to pay required contributions for hours worked from August 2025 through May 2026. Plaintiffs served the summons and complaint on McGrath at 2800 Industrial Drive, Fairfield, California on July 21, 2026. After McGrath failed to appear or defend, the Clerk of the Court entered default on September 14, 2026. On October 2, 2026, plaintiffs moved for entry of default judgment under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 55(b)(2), serving the motion by mail and providing supporting declarations extending the accounting through August 2026. McGrath filed no opposition, prompting the court to vacate the scheduled hearing under Civil Local Rule 7-1(b) and decide the motion on the record.
The Court’s Holding
United States District Judge William H. Orrick granted plaintiffs' motion for default judgment, finding that subject-matter jurisdiction, personal jurisdiction, and service of process were established. The court confirmed jurisdiction under LMRA Section 301 and ERISA Sections 502 and 515, as well as personal jurisdiction over McGrath as a California corporation doing business in the district. Analyzing the Ninth Circuit's Eitel factors, the court concluded that all seven factors favored default judgment. Absent entry of judgment, plaintiffs would suffer prejudice because they had no other recourse to recover delinquent contributions or enforce the agreements. Accepting well-pleaded complaint allegations as true upon default, the court determined that plaintiffs demonstrated a strong showing of success on the merits through detailed evidentiary declarations and exhibits detailing monthly delinquencies.
The court found the monetary sum at stake reasonable and authorized under ERISA and the agreements, the potential for factual disputes unlikely, and no showing of excusable neglect. Although public policy favors deciding cases on their merits, that preference did not preclude default judgment where a nonparticipating defendant prevented adversarial resolution. The court awarded plaintiffs $171,018.53 in unpaid principal fringe benefit contributions, $111,136.53 in liquidated damages, $20,227.82 in prejudgment interest, and $3,915.00 in attorney fees and costs, comprising 15.6 hours at $225 per hour plus filing fees. Conversely, the court denied plaintiffs' unbriefed request for a permanent injunction against future reporting and contribution defaults, noting that the request appeared only once in the motion's introduction without factual or legal justification.
Key Takeaways
- Multiemployer plan fiduciaries seeking default judgment under ERISA Section 515 must submit detailed evidentiary declarations and auditing records demonstrating the precise calculation of monthly delinquent principal, statutory interest, and liquidated damages.
- An employer's failure to answer a properly served complaint concedes substantive liability under the LMRA and ERISA, leaving only the scope and calculation of damages for independent judicial verification.
- The general judicial preference favoring resolution on the merits does not shield a completely nonparticipating party when procedural prerequisites and the Ninth Circuit Eitel factors warrant default judgment.
- District courts will decline prospective permanent injunctive relief in ERISA delinquency cases where the moving fiduciaries fail to provide supporting facts or legal argument establishing traditional equitable prerequisites.
Why It Matters
This decision underscores standard judicial administration in routine ERISA collection litigation within the Northern District of California, affirming that thoroughly documented accounting records enable trust funds to secure complete statutory recoveries of unpaid contributions, liquidated damages, and reasonable attorney fees on default. The ruling also reinforces that courts will not grant boilerplate permanent injunctive relief compelling future contractual compliance when requested merely in passing, requiring plan fiduciaries to plead and prove independent irreparable injury before obtaining ongoing equitable oversight.