Unreported / Non-Citable
Background
Eduardo Oviedo Morales and Isaias Bautista Castillo were arrested by Immigration and Customs Enforcement officers around 7:00 a.m. on November 16, 2026, while driving to work together on Airport Boulevard in South San Francisco. Three unmarked vehicles pulled them over, and four or five officers approached asking for identification. Bautista Castillo provided his identification, while Oviedo Morales declined. When both men stepped out of their vehicle, officers handcuffed and later ankle-cuffed them. The officers did not identify themselves, did not show a warrant, and provided no explanation for the arrests.
The court noted that documents described as warrants were shown only after transport to 630 Sansome Street in San Francisco. The Form I-200 for Morales, who lives in South San Francisco where he was arrested, omitted his home address, listing instead an address in California City and ordering him to appear there before an immigration judge on December 9, 2026. Bautista Castillo's Form I-200 likewise omitted his residence, listing the California City address and setting a November 30, 2026 hearing.
Petitioners promptly filed a 28 U.S.C. § 2241 habeas corpus petition and an ex parte motion for a temporary restraining order, asserting that their sudden detention violated the Constitution and federal statutes. The record reflected that Morales is forty years old, has resided in the United States for approximately twenty years, works steadily in construction, has no criminal record, and lives with his wife and three United States citizen children. Bautista Castillo is twenty-four years old, has lived in the country for four years, works in construction, attends church, and has no criminal history.
The Court’s Holding
The district court granted the ex parte motion for a temporary restraining order under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 65(b)(1), finding that petitioners demonstrated immediate and irreparable injury would occur before respondents could be heard in opposition. Addressing the merits standards, the court initially stated that petitioners were likely to succeed on the merits, and in its detailed constitutional analysis specifically found under Ninth Circuit authority that petitioners established at least serious questions going to the merits with the balance of hardships tipping sharply in their favor.
Applying the Mathews v. Eldridge due process factors, the court emphasized that freedom from physical restraint lies at the core of Fifth Amendment liberty. Weighing petitioners' private interest in caring for their families and maintaining employment against the risk of erroneous deprivation without procedural safeguards, the court held that due process requires petitioners' immediate release and entitles them to notice and a pre-detention hearing before a neutral decisionmaker prior to re-detention. The court waived security under Rule 65(c) given minimal risk of harm to the government.
Operatively, the court ordered respondents to immediately release petitioners from custody on November 16, 2026, in San Francisco. It enjoined respondents from re-detaining petitioners without notice and a pre-deprivation hearing before a neutral decisionmaker, restrained respondents from removing petitioners from the United States, and ordered that petitioners shall not be deported, removed, or transferred outside the country pending further order. Respondents were directed to file a status report by noon on November 17 stating the release time, respond to the petition with relevant A-file records by November 19, and appear for a hearing on November 24, 2026.
Key Takeaways
- The court granted ex parte emergency relief under Rule 65(b)(1), determining that counsel showed immediate and irreparable harm would occur before respondents could be heard in opposition.
- Addressing the merits, the court noted a likelihood of success and specifically held that petitioners raised serious questions on their due process claims with hardships tipping sharply in their favor.
- Applying Mathews v. Eldridge, the court held that Fifth Amendment liberty requires both immediate release and pre-deprivation notice and a hearing before a neutral decisionmaker prior to any re-detention.
- The operative injunction restrained respondents from removing petitioners and ordered that they not be deported or transferred outside the United States pending further judicial proceedings.
Why It Matters
The order represents an immediate same-day judicial intervention following an immigration arrest, ordering release within hours of detention and establishing a pre-deprivation hearing requirement before any subsequent re-arrest. Although granting emergency relief, the ruling is explicitly temporary: it preserves jurisdictional challenges for orderly determination, expires on November 24, 2026, and leaves ultimate statutory and constitutional questions for resolution after formal briefing and argument.