Unreported / Non-Citable
Background
Plaintiff Stacy Penning sued WebMD LLC on behalf of a putative statewide class over its medicinenet.com website. He alleged that he used the site to research serious medical conditions affecting him and entered search terms describing those conditions, while WebMD knowingly installed Amazon tracking technologies that intercepted and disclosed visitors' communications and identifying information without consent. The First Amended Complaint asserted claims under California Invasion of Privacy Act Sections 631(a) and 632(a) and for common-law intrusion upon seclusion.
WebMD moved under 28 U.S.C. § 1404(a) to transfer the case to the District of New Jersey or, alternatively, to dismiss all three claims under Rule 12(b)(6). The parties agreed the case could have been brought in New Jersey, leaving the discretionary convenience-and-fairness factors. The court found party convenience neutral because transfer would only shift inconvenience, and both districts had local interests because Penning and putative class members were California residents while WebMD's principal place of business was in New Jersey.
The court credited Penning's forum choice despite its reduced weight in a class action because he both resided in the district and was allegedly injured there through his website interactions. It found California's familiarity with its own law only slightly disfavored transfer and treated access to evidence and employee-witness convenience as only slightly favoring transfer, especially because no nonparty witnesses were identified. The court expressly weighed these factors differently from a recent order transferring a similar WebMD case to New Jersey.
The Court’s Holding
On transfer, the court held that the two factors favoring New Jersey did not outweigh Penning's choice of forum, his injury in the district, and California's interest in protecting its consumers. It therefore denied transfer to the District of New Jersey.
On the Section 631(a) claim, the court adopted the view that the statute requires intentional conduct rather than knowledge of illegality. Penning sufficiently alleged that WebMD knowingly installed tracking technology knowing it would disclose user communications for advertising purposes. He also gave fair notice of real-time interception by alleging live traffic analysis showing that Amazon trackers captured full URL requests and search queries contemporaneously while communications were in transit.
The court also sustained the Section 632(a) and intrusion-upon-seclusion claims. Alleged capture of exact webpages and unique medical search terms could support a reasonable expectation of confidentiality even outside a provider-patient relationship, and the sensitivity of searches about Penning's own serious conditions precluded deciding as a matter of law that any intrusion was insubstantial or not highly offensive. The court denied WebMD's motion in its entirety.
Key Takeaways
- A plaintiff's residence and alleged injury in the chosen district can retain meaningful weight against transfer even in a putative class action.
- Allegations that tracking code knowingly installed by a website operator transmits users' communications for advertising can satisfy Section 631(a)'s intent requirement without alleging knowledge that the conduct was illegal.
- Complaints describing real-time capture of full URL requests and search queries can provide fair notice of interception in transit at the pleading stage.
- Unique search terms and specific pages viewed can support a reasonable expectation of privacy, including for medical research conducted outside a patient-provider relationship.
- Whether online tracking of sensitive medical searches is highly offensive generally presents a fact question unsuitable for resolution on a motion to dismiss.
Why It Matters
The ruling joins a developing body of California federal decisions allowing website-tracking privacy claims to move past pleading challenges when complaints identify the mechanism, timing, and content of alleged interception rather than merely reciting statutory elements.
The court's refusal to follow a contrary transfer ruling involving WebMD underscores that § 1404(a) balancing remains case-specific, while its treatment of medical search terms reinforces that the content and sensitivity of browsing data can drive both confidentiality and offensiveness analyses.