Unreported / Non-Citable
Background
Shon Yokely is serving a life sentence for a 1991 drive-by shooting that killed a 14-month-old child and wounded three adults. A jury convicted him of first-degree murder, three counts of attempted murder, and conspiracy to commit murder, and the Court of Appeal affirmed on direct appeal. (3.11-3.16)
At his June 11, 2025 parole suitability hearing, Yokely's attorney objected that the Board could not deny parole because his client would not admit guilt and stated that Yokely maintained he was not involved. The commissioners deferred the objection and said they would accept the facts from the direct appeal as true, but then read those facts into the record and invited Yokely to respond. (3.22-3.30; 4.4-4.18)
Yokely first declined to discuss the crime, but a commissioner pressed him for facts supporting his innocence. He then mentioned that his fingerprints were not found in the vehicle and that he resembled the cooperating witness, after which commissioners asked further questions about the crime. The Board panel denied parole, finding his version implausible and evidence of a lack of self-awareness that bore on current dangerousness. After the superior court denied habeas relief, the Court of Appeal issued an order to show cause and considered whether the Board's questioning and reliance on the resulting statements required a new parole hearing. (4.18-4.29; 5.3-5.26; 5.29-6.7)
The Court’s Holding
The court held that reversal and a new parole hearing were required because the commissioners induced Yokely to discuss the sentenced crimes after he and his attorney repeatedly invoked his right not to discuss them, and then used his denial of culpability as a factor supporting parole denial. (6.10-6.16)
The court explained that Penal Code section 5011, subdivision (b) forbids requiring an admission of guilt and regulation 2236 allows an inmate to refuse to discuss the crime without prejudice. Although the Board may assess the plausibility of an inmate's account when he volunteers one beyond a simple denial, the questioning here was coercive: an inmate in Yokely's position would reasonably understand that continued silence could be held against him. (7.9-7.25; 9.1-9.20)
The court rejected the Attorney General's arguments that the questioning was less extensive than in In re Perez and that Yokely elected to discuss the crime. It found prejudice because the commissioners expressly relied on his innocence claim and the statements they procured when finding a lack of self-awareness and current dangerousness. The petition was granted, the Board's decision vacated, and the matter remanded for a new parole suitability hearing in conformance with the opinion as soon as practicable, with no view expressed on whether parole should ultimately be granted. (9.21-11.5; 12.2-12.8)
Key Takeaways
- A parole panel may not keep questioning an inmate about the commitment crime after the inmate or counsel invokes the statutory and regulatory right to refuse to discuss it.
- An inmate's brief response to a commissioner's invitation to support a claim of innocence does not waive that right when the questioning itself creates pressure to answer.
- The Board may consider a volunteered account that goes beyond a simple denial of guilt, but it may not manufacture an implausibility finding by eliciting the account over an asserted right to remain silent.
- A parole denial cannot stand where the decision expressly relies on the inmate's refusal to admit guilt or on statements obtained through prohibited questioning.
- The remedy for such a violation is vacatur of the parole decision and a new suitability hearing conducted with the protections of Penal Code section 5011 and regulation 2236 fully honored.
Why It Matters
This unpublished decision applies In re Perez and In re Jackson to a hearing where the questioning was shorter but still coercive, confirming that Perez does not set a minimum threshold of aggression or length for a section 5011 violation. The court also made clear that the Board cannot cure the problem by characterizing the inmate's response as voluntary when the record shows repeated invocations of the right to refuse.
Presiding Justice Hoffstadt concurred separately. He agreed the Board impermissibly required an admission of guilt and that the error was prejudicial because the Board expressly relied on the implausibility of Yokely's innocence statements, but he also found that other suitability factors supplied some evidence supporting denial and that the flaw would not have required reversal had the Board made clear it would have reached the same result absent the error. (13.5-13.28)