Reported / Citable
Background
Reach Community Development and several residential tenants of the Gray's Landing apartment complex in Portland, Oregon, brought a civil rights action against the Department of Homeland Security and other federal agencies. The apartment building sits directly across the street from a U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement facility. Over several months, demonstrations outside the facility prompted federal officers to deploy crowd-control munitions, including tear gas, pepper spray, and synthetic irritants, to disperse crowds engaged in property destruction, laser strikes, and clashes with officers.
Plaintiffs alleged that chemical munitions regularly drifted into Gray's Landing, entering courtyards and private residences and causing severe physical irritation, respiratory distress, and skin reactions among adult residents and young children. Claiming a violation of their substantive due process rights under the Fifth Amendment, plaintiffs sought preliminary injunctive relief. The district court granted a preliminary injunction prohibiting federal officers from deploying tear gas to disperse crowds outside the facility.
A Ninth Circuit motions panel previously stayed the preliminary injunction pending appeal, concluding that plaintiffs failed to identify an established liberty interest grounded in the nation's history and tradition. The federal defendants then pursued plenary interlocutory appeal of the preliminary injunction, asking the court of appeals to vacate the injunction on the threshold ground that plaintiffs could show no likelihood of success on the merits.
The Court’s Holding
The Ninth Circuit vacated the district court's preliminary injunction, holding that plaintiffs have no likelihood of success on the merits because they lack a substantive due process right to be free from the government's deployment of non-lethal crowd-control devices during disruptive demonstrations. Writing for the panel, Judge Eric C. Tung explained that under Washington v. Glucksberg and Dobbs v. Jackson Women's Health Organization, any unwritten substantive due process right must be carefully described and shown to be deeply rooted in the nation's history and tradition and implicit in the concept of ordered liberty.
The panel rejected plaintiffs' contention that challenges to executive action need only satisfy the shocks-the-conscience standard under County of Sacramento v. Lewis. Following circuit precedent in Brittain v. Hansen, the panel held that a plaintiff challenging executive action must satisfy both requirements: proving that the action shocks the conscience and establishing the deprivation of a carefully described liberty interest deeply rooted in national history. Because non-lethal crowd-control tools have long been used by law enforcement and plaintiffs identified no historical prohibition against them, plaintiffs failed the threshold historical inquiry. The majority therefore ended its inquiry and expressly declined to decide whether the government's conduct shocked the conscience.
Judge Ana de Alba dissented, concluding that executive-action challenges should be governed by the shocks-the-conscience test alone pursuant to Lewis and Martinez v. City of Oxnard. In her view, the extensive district court record demonstrated deliberate indifference by federal officers, who repeatedly deployed heavy quantities of chemical irritants into residential areas, acted contrary to agency use-of-force policies, disregarded community notices of harm, and allegedly deployed chemical munitions for social media content creation.
Key Takeaways
- To succeed on a substantive due process challenge to executive action in the Ninth Circuit, a plaintiff must show both that the government's action shocks the conscience and that it deprives a carefully described liberty interest deeply rooted in national history.
- Neighboring residents and bystanders possess no recognized constitutional due process right to be free from incidental exposure to non-lethal crowd-control munitions deployed by law enforcement during civil demonstrations.
- Broad assertions of bodily integrity cannot circumvent the threshold requirement under Glucksberg and Dobbs to establish that the specifically asserted right is grounded in historical practice.
- A plaintiff's failure to establish a likelihood of success on the merits terminates preliminary injunction inquiry and requires vacatur of preliminary injunctive relief under the Winter framework.
Why It Matters
This decision solidifies a dual-requirement hurdle in the Ninth Circuit for substantive due process challenges against executive action, foreclosing efforts to rely exclusively on the shocks-the-conscience standard without proving a historically grounded liberty interest. By applying this requirement strictly to the collateral effects of non-lethal police crowd-control tactics, the panel sharply limits constitutional tort exposure for bystanders and residents affected by law enforcement operations.
The sharp division between the majority and the dissent underscores an ongoing circuit debate over whether executive conduct causing collateral injury can be reached under substantive due process without eighteenth-century historical analogues, effectively confining bystander claims to traditional common-law tort regimes.